Kimberly and Katie - ADWDL
500 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Kimberly and Katie are professional true crime TV experts with no formal training but evidence lockers filled with snark and uninformed opinions. Katie watches Dateline in hopes to learn how to prevent her new husband from murdering her for the life insurance money, and Kimberly watches so she'll know what to say when Keith Morrison interviews her about her best friend Katie's murder.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Kimberly and Katie pair close Dateline recaps with probing questions, humane attention, and humor that stays clear of the victims.
A Date With Dateline turns televised true crime into a lively conversation between Kimberly and Katie. Their recaps follow Dateline's case chronology while pausing over unclear testimony, investigative gaps, and details that deserve more explanation.
Keith Morrison gets crowned 'our leaning king'; you get Kimberly and Katie's running commentary.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A coffee-shop phone clue leads into cliff country as Kimberly and Katie weigh how much danger Andrea should take on.
The Gorge works best when it lets the park do the unsettling work. Cell phones left at a coffee shop, rivers and cliffs narrowing the search, and men moving down a steep hill on ropes give the episode a clear physical pull.
A public trial sharpens around an au pair's Instagram trail, where a hidden face and a watch become difficult to dismiss.
Temptation frames a public trial around the strain between a stated professional relationship and a trail of social-media posts that appears to tell a less tidy story.
A warm movie crossover where horror memories and car decals pull the conversation into funny, strange territory.
That Aged Well Crossover! pairs Kimberly with Paul and Erica from That Aged Well for a relaxed, funny double date built around old movies, TV shows, and the awkward question of which favorites still hold up.
Eric's prison fight for appeal turns on a disputed statement signed by a sixteen-year-old witness.
Eric has no appeals left, but he keeps pressing forward. In prison, he takes college classes, studies the law, and continues working on his case. After his final appeal fails in 2006, he meets Sister Joanna Chan, who prays with him and urges him to keep his faith.
A single pin at Apartment 210 opens into a tight, conversational investigation.
This Date with Dateline repeat stays centered on a single pin at Apartment 210, then broadens through Jazzy's overnight bag, her credit cards and driver's license, and the notebook with Jason Chen written on it.
A repeat Dateline episode that turns an Easter Sunday mismatch, a winter Vegas setting, and a Walmart alibi into sharp true-crime banter.
Part of the Plan is a repeat Dateline episode that lands on Easter Sunday, and Kimberly and Katie lean into the mismatch as part of the humor. The winter setting and Las Vegas backdrop give the conversation an odd charge, while the Walmart detail becomes the sharpest comic beat.
A messy affair-driven murder case with enough reversals to keep the pressure on.
The Widow of Woodland Hills follows Monica and Rob through a murder case that keeps shifting between affair tension, detective pressure, and courtroom maneuvering.
Anniversary banter and a rare Sunday Dateline drop lead into a very odd Ms Pumpkin discussion.
A Date With Dateline opens with anniversary banter and a thank-you to listeners and Dateline, then leans into the loose, pointed chat that defines the show.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
Patrick Radden Keefe investigates whether the CIA secretly wrote a Scorpions hit.
Jake Halpern and the Snowball team track a con artist who defrauded a family.
A city-by-city true-crime documentary, from Detroit's Kwame Kilpatrick scandal to mob confessions.
A murder rumor in rural Alabama unravels into a clockmaker's suicide and estate feud.
Kimberly and Katie analyze a Dateline episode about chiropractor Mary Yoder, poisoned with colchicine in Central New York.
Kimberly and Katie analyze Dateline's jailhouse interview with Lori Vallow Daybell, discussing her combative demeanor, delusional beliefs, and the horrific details of the murders of her children and others.
Katie and Jake analyze episode two of the Gilgo Beach Killer series, focusing on Rex Heuermann's arrest and its impact on his family.
Kimberly and Katie analyze a Dateline episode about the Idaho student murders, focusing on the suspect Brian Koberger's social isolation, incel ideology, and stalking behavior leading up to the crime.
Kimberly and Katie recap Dateline's 'Secrets of the Sliding Door,' covering the murder of teacher Simonette Mapes Krupe by her husband Jonathan, who was secretly seeing an escort named Miss Pumpkin.
Kimberly and Katie analyze a Dateline episode about Natalie Cochran, who faked cancer and ran a Ponzi scheme selling guns and pills to the government, while being investigated for possibly murdering her husband Michael with insulin.
In the cold open, April 12th becomes National Dateline Day, and Kimberly and Katie leap from fundraiser housekeeping into a Woodland Hills case with a title that pretty much tells on itself.
Blainiacs get their knife and train night.
Barely a repeat, and somehow already on the request list.
Washington state gets pulled into the mess.
Kimberly and Katie analyze the Hulu documentary 'Little Miss Innocent,' covering the murder of chiropractor Mary Yoder.
Kimberly and Katie analyze a Dateline episode about Nathan Payette's murder in Las Vegas, where his wife Michelle conspired with coworker Michael Rodriguez for life insurance money.
Kimberly and Katie analyze a Dateline episode about the 2002 double murder of Mark Sisko and Karen Harkness in Kansas, focusing on the prime suspect Dana Chandler, Mike's obsessive ex-wife.
The hosts analyze the first episode of 'Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets,' covering the initial investigation into the Long Island serial killer case, including victim profiles, key evidence like burner phones and a Chevy Avalanche, and how police corruption delayed justice for over a decade.
["Grace Koo gets a text asking, \u201cdo you know where Alice is?\u201d, and the family learns that 37-year-old Alice has been out of contact for two weeks.", "Andrea Canning\u2019s Dateline episode sends the search from Sunnyvale to Taiwan and Taroko National Park after Alice\u2019s passport enters Taiwan but never leaves.", "Harold Hurchin, a Stanford-trained engineer with 60 patents and a third marriage, gives investigators a young-driver story that does not fit the phone or license-plate data.", "Kimberly and Katie also focus on the printed \u201cWelcome home, Alice\u201d note, the secret marriage, the $1 million refinance tied to Melissa\u2019s death, and the family\u2019s use of Andrew Waters and Todd Davis to force answers."]
A Date With Dateline's Temptation follows a February 2023 shooting in Fairfax County, Virginia, after IRS special agent Brendan Banfield calls 911 to report a stranger in his house.
A Date With Dateline and That Aged Well spend the crossover laughing about a West Side Highway car decal that reads 'position open' and sounds like a Dateline setup.
A Date With Dateline recaps Dateline's A Bronx Tale, Season 23, Episode 20, which aired June 6, 2014 and centers on Eric Glisson's fight to overturn a 1995 Bronx conviction.
A Date with Dateline reviews the May 2016 disappearance and killing of 25-year-old Shantae Blankenship in Brownwood, Texas, after she left for a walk on Friday the 13th.
The hosts discuss the Dateline episode on the Delphi murders, sharing their uninformed opinions and snarky commentary.
The hosts discuss a Dateline episode about a missing person case, providing humorous and opinionated commentary.
The hosts discuss the Dateline episode 'Obsession' about the Analisa Raymundo case, with a guest co-host.
The hosts interview Dateline correspondent Andrea Canning, discussing her most dangerous assignments and her interview with convicted murderer Remy Ramsaran.
Two hosts recap and humorously analyze a Dateline episode about the trial of Stephen Beale for murder.