A Date With Dateline · Kimberly and Katie - ADWDL

Murder in MInot S.33 Ep.26

·1 hr 38 min·5 clips

Tyler arranges Anita's funeral slideshow and calls police repeatedly—is he a grieving friend or a suspect?

Kimberly and Katie open on the Blainiacs nickname, then get into a Dateline recap that keeps snagging on evidence, timing, and very shaky confidence. The train timestamp matters. One man seems to reach town after the murder, which should clear some space around him, but the trip details stay thin enough to keep everyone squinting. Naturally, the train-hopper riff arrives. The hosts will not let a vague arrival harden into a clean answer before they have pictured the whole thing as a Hopalong Cassidy bit. Then Aunt Clarice trips up the knife story. The relative who seemed to tie Devin to a knife says the knife in the picture is not the same knife after all. That is not a small correction. Kimberly and Katie treat it like the mess it is, because a person got dragged toward murder suspicion on a memory that did not hold. The knife gets its own little investigation too. A wolf, an Indian-head coin image, a headdress reference, and a fancy handle all turn into the kind of visual trivia Dateline can accidentally promote into evidence with a speaking role. The hosts pause over the wording, trying to name the image without making the language worse. Then outside information drains the drama. The odd, traceable knife starts looking more like a common flea market find, which makes the whole thing feel less like a smoking gun and more like something from a crowded drawer. By the end, a Post-it has somehow become a police office disaster scene: bad glue, a fan, a Rube Goldberg mess, and a neck-cut hypothetical nobody needed. The tangent is ridiculous, and it knows it. That is the balance here. The case stays serious, while every strange procedural detail gets room to wobble and be roasted.

As heard by us

A conversational recap that keeps the knife mix-up and suspect timeline in focus.

Murder in Minot is a Dateline recap that keeps its attention on the mistake at the center of the case. Kimberly and Katie work through the knife mix-up, the suspect timeline, and the question of whether the first theory holds up, which gives the discussion its edge.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want one knife mix-up and one off-kilter timeline to do the heavy lifting.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Date With Dateline