Menahot 89: On Lighting the Menorah and Libations

·19 min·1 clip

Anne Gordon and Yerdena Azband explore Menachot 89, revealing how the Temple menorah required three and a half logs of oil.

The episode begins with hosts Anne Gordon and Yerdena Azband introducing Menachot page 89. They focus on a Gemara section about the oil needed for the Temple menorah, specifying three and a half logs total. The hosts explain this corresponds to a half-log per lamp for the seven-branched menorah. They contrast this with modern Hanukkah menorahs and mention the Arch of Titus depiction. The Gemara cites a verse from Shemot where Aaron arranges the menorah from evening to morning. Two methods are presented for determining the oil amount: starting with a large quantity and reducing it, or starting small and increasing it. These reflect principles about sparing Jewish communal funds versus not worrying about cost in a wealthy context. The discussion turns to the economics of olive oil, noting its expense and the dedication required for Temple offerings. Anne observes the prevalence of olive trees in Israel. The episode then shifts to a Mishnah about mixing libations (nisachim) that accompany animal sacrifices. It states libations for bulls and rams can be mixed due to similar ingredient ratios, but not those for lambs with bulls. The Mishnah also addresses the lamb brought with the Omer offering, whose flour amount is doubled but oil and wine are not. The hosts mention the Gemara will address a contradiction with this statement. They reference Rabbi Yochanan's opinion about a metzora's asham sacrifice requiring libations even if slaughtered incorrectly. This leads to a broader discussion on how integral libations were to sacrifices, often overlooked in modern prayer contexts. The hosts reflect on the complexity and richness of Temple rituals.

As heard by us

A careful look at the oil, grain, wine, and labor behind Temple offerings.

Talking Talmud treats Menachot 89 as a close look at the Temple's operating demands, from oil for the menorah to grain offerings, wine libations, and the ratios that decide what may be combined.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Talmud page where the olive oil bill stays visible.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Talking Talmud