A warm Broadway-night conversation full of backstage memory and lived-in theater talk.
Nicholas Connell's visit lands as a Broadway-night hangout, with Maria keeping the tone warm and close to the people and places around the work.

Maria Gentile
126 episodes listed below
Creative rooms, live chatter, big affection.
What’s the Story with Maria is a loose, affectionate tableful of cabaret, theater, film, music, food, travel, and neighborhood news. Episodes move from shout-outs and personal stories into interviews with artists, often keeping the live-chat warmth and room-to-room energy intact.
PRESS PLAY
What’s the Story with Maria is an arts-community talk show with the relaxed charge of a live room. It opens warmly, often with hellos, dates, plugs, and the sense that half the audience may already know each other. Then it wanders, happily and usefully. Broadway openings, cabaret rooms, queer cinema, solo theater, Oscar talk, holiday memories, Paris travel, and family stories all move through the same conversational doorway. The show is especially rooted in nightlife and performance culture, with recurring attention to places like the Stonewall Inn, Don’t Tell Mama, Joe’s Pub, The Green Room 42, Brandy’s, and the Gay Community Center. Its arts coverage is personal rather than distant. Nicholas Connell can talk about Titanic, John Riddle, Nicole Parker, improv, and writing songs onstage; Mel England and Billy Clift can move into queer film history and the continuing need for ordinary, heartfelt gay love stories. A live Stonewall Inn episode carries celebration and community history in the same breath. A Neil Sedaka tribute becomes a chain of memory, gratitude, piano stories, and friendship. The show also has room for recurring favorites, food jokes, family check-ins, audience comments, and quick local performance announcements. Leo’s promo and technical presence gives the live format a familiar rhythm, while Maria’s on-air style keeps returning to praise, thanks, and connection. It is not a tightly packaged critic’s desk. That is the appeal. The show feels like an archive of overlapping creative circles, where a singer, filmmaker, festival leader, friend, relative, live commenter, or nightlife regular can suddenly become part of the story. Its politics and grief arrive through people rather than position papers. Its comedy comes from timing, affection, and the occasional chaotic handoff. For listeners who like interviews with visible fingerprints, it offers something intimate: art discussed by people still standing near the stage door.
Made for: For listeners who follow cabaret, theater, queer arts, nightlife, and community-rooted interviews. It also fits anyone who enjoys warm, digressive conversations where personal memory matters as much as the official topic.
What sets it apart: The show stands apart by preserving the texture of a live community gathering: shout-outs, venue news, family asides, technical handoffs, and guest stories all remain part of the experience. It feels less like a media circuit stop than a living address book of artists and friends.
"I Like to Celebrate and Promote my Creative Friends!"MARIA GENTILE: Actor, MAC Award Winning Entertainer, Singer/Songwriter, NYC Nightlife Piano Bar staple AND a FANTASTIC Cook! Maria's guests are artists of all mediums, sharing their stories and how they keep their art ALIVE! Entertaining, Fresh, Informative and FUN! Join Maria every Tuesday at 9pm LIVE on Facebook and Youtube and all of our audio replays. whatsthestorywithmaria.com
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Maria makes creative work legible through candid conversations about rehearsal, collaboration, performance and the personal histories artists carry into the room.
Maria treats an arts interview as an extension of the dressing room, rehearsal studio and piano bar. Conversations move easily between work in progress and the relationships around it: John Bronston discusses a Golden Boy concert at 54 Below, Nicholas Connell recalls improvising…
Maria's piano-bar table gives you Broadway shop talk with the friends-only filter removed.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A warm Broadway-night conversation full of backstage memory and lived-in theater talk.
Nicholas Connell's visit lands as a Broadway-night hangout, with Maria keeping the tone warm and close to the people and places around the work.
A cozy, chatty evening of guest banter, neighborhood warmth, and affectionate detours.
This episode works best when the room feels lived in. Maria keeps the conversation loose and close to the crowd, with familiar guests, show updates, affectionate back-and-forth, and a steady stream of small mentions that keep the mood warm.
A warm queer-film conversation with real history under the banter.
Mel England and Billy Clift carry a warm, chatty conversation about queer filmmaking, the early indie gay cinema that shaped it, and the pull of stories about ordinary lives.
A warm tribute that treats memory like conversation, not ceremony.
Maria turns a Tuesday-night set into a tribute to Neil Sedaka, and the heart of it is plain gratitude. She comes across as someone who asked questions, listened, and made other people feel seen.
A warm, lightly meandering conversation about Golden Boy from rehearsal to performance.
Maria keeps the focus on a warm Tuesday-night talk around a new Golden Boy concert at 54 Below, and the guest list gives the segment a pleasantly crowded feel.



Queer stereotypes, sharpened and set loose.

Queer pop culture, loudly and lovingly overread.

Blunt talk on sex, identity, and desire.

Quick hits with working entertainers.
April 14th, 2026 feels celebratory right away.
Tuesday, April 7th, 2026, starts with Maria welcoming everyone, lining up Barbara and Susan Campanaro in Florida, and pulling Chris in before his show next Tuesday.
Maria introduces her long-awaited guest Anthony Valbiro, discussing the rejuvenating arrival of spring and a hopeful moment involving a Mr.
Maria hosts a live episode from the Stonewall Inn in NYC, celebrating LGBTQ+ community and activism with special guest Tree.
Maria introduces the episode with a St.
March 10, 2026 starts warm, with Maria and Leo welcoming Mel England and film director Billy Clift alongside Danielle Alexandria Alchemy, WFMU friends, and the live chat.
Maria is gutted.
Tuesday, February 17th, Maria opens the table, and the room fills fast: John Bronston beside Frank Zahn, Christy Cates and Peter McIntosh on Zoom, everyone circling the 54 Below concert Golden Boy.
Host Maria celebrates the 400th episode of her podcast with special guests Jonathan Liebson, a writer with a new book, and Cathy Roy-Spies, director of education at the Mayo Performing Arts Center, while sharing excitement about her recent performance at Green Room 42.
Maria hosts an interview with iconic artists Lorraine Leckie and Billy Leroy, focusing on their creative lives and joyful personal stories.
Maria interviews her longtime friend Mario Cantone, reminiscing about how they met in high school through summer theater productions and their shared history.
Maria promotes her upcoming live show at Green Room 42 on May 25th, 2025, featuring guests Shawn Ryan and Sudi Rick Karatas, while sharing details about a new poster designed by Kenny Holcomb.
Maria introduces an upcoming interview with icons Elysze Held and Diane D'Angelo while promoting her live show at Green Room 42.