The Bakersfield Three

Casefile Presents

23 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

A cold case built from contradictions.

The gist

The Bakersfield Three follows the tangled cases around James, Bailey, and Micah through interviews, police audio, timelines, and family memory. It moves slowly and deliberately, giving weight to contradictions, witness accounts, addiction, loss, and the small pieces of evidence that refuse to settle.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About The Bakersfield Three

The Bakersfield Three is a long-form true-crime investigation about cases that do not stay in separate boxes. James is killed. Bailey and Micah disappear. Around them, the series builds a dense map of friends, partners, family members, rumors, searches, police interviews, and memories that keep pulling the story in different directions. The show is patient. It often returns to a known detail, refreshes the timeline, and then asks why that detail still feels unsettled. A chiropractor's house becomes important. So does a car, a shower door, a missing toilet tank lid, and searches about glass and caustic material. The series does not treat these as instant proof. It treats them as pressure points in a story where too many explanations sound partial. Family voices carry much of the weight. Jane's search for Bailey, including the destroyed flyers and hostile messages around them, gives the reporting a raw, public-facing grief. Di's fight for James' case gives the series another emotional anchor, especially after the update about her death from ovarian cancer. Ryan's account brings James' family story into view, including addiction, regret, and the difficulty of living near a violent loss. The show also spends time with Shirley's disappearance and her quiet life as a caregiver, showing how older pain can shape a life long before a case becomes public. It is not a fast puzzle box. It is closer to a case file being read beside people who cannot put it down. Chad Garrett's work on James' and Bailey's cases gives the reporting a continuing investigative path, while interviews with figures such as Matt Vandekastiel, Sarah, Sarah G, Elizabeth, and others add friction, confusion, and sometimes pain. The series is especially attentive to contradiction: who was where, who knew what, who changed a story, and which details may have been dismissed too quickly. Its strongest moments come when a small oddity becomes a real question. The tone stays sober and emotionally present. It does not chase spectacle. It follows the damage left behind when violence, disappearance, addiction, and silence are all part of the same neighborhood story.

Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer careful reporting, family testimony, and unresolved timelines over tidy reveals. It suits anyone drawn to missing-persons cases, homicide investigations, and stories where grief and evidence are impossible to separate.

What sets it apart: The series stands apart through its accumulation of lived-in detail: flyers pulled down, recorded calls, police interview fragments, search histories, and family memories all become part of the record. It is investigative without losing sight of the people still carrying the cases.

In their own words

When two friends go missing back-to-back, and in between their disappearances, a third friend is murdered, their mothers begin their own investigation. As the connections between the three cases are explored, the mothers navigate devastating twists and turns, including one revelation that shakes the community to its core. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

As heard by us

Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Careful timelines and person-first reporting bring clarity to three intertwined cases without forcing uncertain evidence into a tidy conclusion.

The Bakersfield Three builds its serialized investigation through careful returns to the intertwined cases of James, Micah, and Bailey. The host reconstructs timelines, distinguishes people with similar names, and places police interviews beside digital searches and conflicting…

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A replaced shower door becomes the kind of detail that keeps you mentally reopening the case.

Press play if you want

  • the timeline before the theory, especially when suspicious searches and missing bathroom fixtures begin to rhyme
  • victims and their families treated as people, not merely pieces waiting on a case board
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
linked disappearances and murderfamily-led searchespolice interviews and recorded callsconflicting witness accountsaddiction and griefmissing-person flyersBakersfield case timelinessmall evidence details

Talks about

Best episodes of The Bakersfield Three

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Episode 18: The ChiropractorMay 20, 2025

A careful, uneasy look at the people around James Kolstad's final night.

Episode 18 keeps James Kolstad's killing anchored to the chiropractor's house and the people around it, and it never pretends the timeline is simple.

Episode 17: LILOct 22, 2024

A restrained episode that finds its tension in Shirley's life before it ever reaches the case.

The episode turns the Bakersfield Three case toward Shirley and lets her disappearance carry the tension. It moves from the missing car and untouched belongings into the plain facts of her life: a very quiet routine, caregiving work, time at her local Baptist church, no social…

Episode 16: A Thousand Different Colors of GrayMay 21, 2024

A steady, unsettling turn through timelines, house details, and searches that keep the Bakersfield 3 case in focus.

The episode stays with the Bakersfield 3 case and keeps its attention on timelines, messages, and household details that begin to align. It gives the March 23 window room to breathe, returns to the broken shower door at Vanda Castiel's house, and threads in the searches tied to…

Episode 6: Polaroid PictureNov 7, 2023

A missing-person case grows uglier as the search itself starts to warp the story.

Jane keeps the episode tethered to a simple fear that never stays simple for long: a daughter is missing, and the public story around that loss starts to turn sour.

Episode 4: Strawberries and OceansNov 7, 2023

A grief-heavy chapter that turns a murder case into a measured look at addiction's damage.

This episode tracks the aftermath of James Colstead's murder by moving from a deadly weekend in Bakersfield to the people still carrying the loss.

Podcasts like The Bakersfield Three

Episodes

  1. 1

    Episode 18: The Chiropractor

    James Kolstad's killing still will not line up neatly.

    May 20, 2025·30m·2 clips
  2. 2

    Casefile Presents: The Unthinkable

    Nov 11, 2024·3m
  3. 3

    Episode 17: LIL

    A human leg washes ashore at Lake Buena Vista, and the reporting turns toward Shirley, a quiet caregiver whose car was missing while her belongings stayed untouched.

    Oct 22, 2024·25m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Casefile Presents: Missing Niamh

    Sep 23, 2024·5m
  5. 5

    Casefile Presents: Troubled Waters

    Jun 16, 2024·4m
  6. 6

    The Bakersfield Three YouTube series

    May 29, 2024·1m
  7. 7

    Episode 16: A Thousand Different Colors of Gray

    The Bakersfield 3 revisits the case with a hard update and a closer read on the March 23rd timeline.

    May 21, 2024·48m·3 clips
  8. 8

    Casefile Presents: The Easey Street Murders

    Feb 19, 2024·4m
  9. 9

    Episode 13: Boogeyman

    Nov 7, 2023·47m
  10. 10

    Episode 5: Crazy Beautiful

    Nov 7, 2023·52m
  11. 11

    Episode 12: Bread Crumbs

    Nov 7, 2023·38m
  12. 12

    Episode 10: River Arrest

    Nov 7, 2023·23m
  13. 13

    Episode 9: Mobsters, Motorcycles, and Monsters

    Nov 7, 2023·33m
  14. 14

    Episode 8: Blue Christmas

    Nov 7, 2023·22m
  15. 15

    Episode 3: Yellow Rose

    Nov 7, 2023·33m
  16. 16

    Episode 2: Facebook Official

    Nov 7, 2023·36m
  17. 17

    Episode 1: Fight Like a Mother

    Nov 7, 2023·26m
  18. 18

    Episode 6: Polaroid Picture

    Jane's flyers keep coming down.

    Nov 7, 2023·22m·2 clips
  19. 19

    Episode 14: Judgement Day

    Nov 7, 2023·46m
  20. 20

    Episode 15: Waiting for the Wave to Crash

    Nov 7, 2023·41m
  21. 21

    Episode 4: Strawberries and Oceans

    James was changing.

    Nov 7, 2023·35m·3 clips
  22. 22

    Episode 11: All the Sins

    Nov 7, 2023·46m
  23. 23

    Episode 7: Bone of my Bones, Flesh of my Flesh

    Nov 7, 2023·22m