A family cocaine arrest turns into a sharp look at clemency, power, and second chances.
Part 5 of Pretend opens with a cousin's 1995 cocaine arrest and uses that family shock to widen the frame to clemency, mercy, and who gets to bend the rules.

True crime about trust turned into leverage.
PRETEND is a true-crime reporting show about scams, impersonation, stalking, counterfeit goods, and political access. It favors patient casework over spectacle, keeping attention on how victims are targeted and how institutions respond.
PRESS PLAY
PRETEND is a reported true-crime show about deception, pressure, and the damage left after someone exploits trust. Its cases range widely, but the pattern is steady: a person or institution gains power by making others believe something false. Recent episodes follow a pardon series that looks at clemency from several angles. One thread examines women in prison, mercy petitions, and the narrow path left after appeals fail. Another follows Joseph Schwartz, a nursing-home operator tied to tax crimes, medical fraud, political operatives, and a search for relief. The show also covers financial fraud against retirees, counterfeit products with real physical risks, and people impersonating ICE agents to terrorize or assault others. It does not treat scams as puzzles detached from consequences. Victims remain central. The reporting keeps returning to lost savings, unsafe care, police raids, fear at the door, and families forced to live around threats. The narration is brisk and plainspoken, with enough edge to match the subject matter. It can sound incredulous, but the structure stays journalistic. Interviews are used to explain what happened and why the system behaved as it did. Attorneys, victims, and case subjects help turn dense legal material into something legible. The show is especially sharp when it connects individual misconduct to wider incentives, from lobbying and political access to understaffed care facilities and online harassment forums. PRETEND also leaves room for uncertainty when competing accounts exist. That restraint matters in stories built around accusation and denial. The result is crime storytelling for listeners who want more than a villain reveal. PRETEND asks how the con worked, who enabled it, and why accountability so often arrives late.
Made for: For listeners drawn to scams, white-collar crime, legal reporting, cyberstalking cases, and stories where the harm is social as much as criminal. It suits people who prefer documented, victim-aware reporting over sensational mystery packaging.
What sets it apart: PRETEND stands apart by connecting individual deception to the systems around it: courts, clemency, nursing homes, online forums, immigration fear, and consumer supply chains. The show makes fraud feel concrete without turning victims into props.
PRETEND is an investigative true crime podcast about real people who lie for a living — con artists, scammers, and the victims caught in their web. Hosted by journalist Javier Leiva, PRETEND exposes the human psychology behind deception and fraud. Each episode follows a real case of manipulation — from financial scams and Ponzi schemes to digital hoaxes and emotional cons. PRETEND explains how and why deception works without shaming victims, combining ethical journalism with cinematic storytelling. Featured in lists of the best podcasts about con artists and scams, PRETEND investigates crimes of persuasion, trust, and betrayal. New episodes drop regularly with stor...
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
PRETEND makes scams, harassment, counterfeiting, and clemency cases understandable by following the people, institutions, and disputed claims behind them.
PRETEND follows deception into the systems that let it work. Javier Leiva builds investigative narratives from interviews, records, competing accounts, and careful explanation, moving from Doug Williams's campaign against polygraph testing to the sustained cyberstalking…
One dirty energy-drink factory, and suddenly you want to inspect every convenience-store shelf.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A family cocaine arrest turns into a sharp look at clemency, power, and second chances.
Part 5 of Pretend opens with a cousin's 1995 cocaine arrest and uses that family shock to widen the frame to clemency, mercy, and who gets to bend the rules.
A sharp corruption story about power, money, and clemency.
The episode follows Joseph Schwartz from a pizzeria office in New Jersey into a nursing home empire, and that jump gives the story its bite. It moves cleanly from insurance sales to Skyline Healthcare, then to the scale of more than 100 facilities across 11 states, before…
A measured opening to a case about medicine, parental rights, and a child's safety.
Season seven opens by revisiting Maya Kowalski and Take Care of Maya, but the focus stays on the clash between parental authority, hospital responsibility, and a child's care turning into a legal fight.
A legal takedown story where counterfeit commerce turns into a public-safety threat.
The episode follows Jeffrey Potter, an anti-counterfeiting lawyer at Patterson, Belknap, Webb, and Tyler, as he goes after fake goods that can do real harm. It stays close to the work itself: civil raids with the U.S.
A hard-edged account of repeated swattings, bomb threats, and the toll of a long harassment campaign.
The episode follows a harassment campaign that has made ordinary life feel unstable, with more than 40 swattings, at least half a dozen bomb threats, and the constant pressure of not knowing what comes next.
A sharp, character-led look at Doug Williams and his fight with the polygraph industry.
The Lie Detector Revisited follows Doug Williams, the former Oklahoma City police officer who took on the polygraph industry, and it works best as a personal story. The host says he was the last person to interview Williams, and that detail gives the episode a quiet charge.
A clean refresher on the McDonald's prank story, ending with one of Pretend's strangest calls.
This episode folds the McDonald's hoax prank into a cleaner pass through parts one and two, giving listeners enough context before Don't Pick Up the Phone arrives on Netflix.

True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.

Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.

Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.

Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.

iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.

A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.
453 kilograms of cocaine, $63 million in value, and a 60-year Illinois sentence define the Edie's clemency case that drives this Pretend episode.
This episode of PRETEND investigates Joseph Schwartz, who built a nursing home empire through Skyline Healthcare while neglecting elderly residents and committing Medicaid fraud.
Javier opens by pausing his own series, pointing listeners to Andrea Dunlop’s season seven of Nobody Should Believe Me, and framing Take Care of Maya as the reference point.
Jeffrey Potter tells Javier Leyva how a counterfeit Five-Hour Energy operation was traced with civil search orders, U.S.
A widow recounts how her husband's sudden death led her to trust a financial advisor who mismanaged her investments.
This episode explores the rise of con artists and fraud, highlighting the staggering financial losses and the systemic failures that allow criminals to escape consequences while victims suffer.
This episode investigates the five-year cyberstalking campaign against Patrick and Nikki Tomlinson, including swatting, bomb threats, and legal battles.
A true crime podcast episode documenting multiple cases of individuals impersonating ICE agents to commit crimes like rape, robbery, and kidnapping across the United States.
Host Javier welcomes Patreon listener Christine Harnose for a bonus recap episode of the podcast.
An investigation into whether a psychic medium researches clients beforehand, raising ethical questions about charging grieving parents for readings.
A skeptical critique of psychic medium Matt Fraser's claims and his online group reading event, debunking the idea that spirits are more active near Halloween.
Javier hosts a live AMA about the making of his podcast Pretend, co-hosted by Patreon supporter Katie Watson, and teases an upcoming series on psychic stings.
Doug Williams says a polygraph is "about as accurate as a coin toss," and Javier Leyva centers the episode on the former Oklahoma City police officer who built a business teaching people how to beat the test.
["Pretend's \"The Prank\" follows police-impersonation calls that pushed McDonald's and other fast-food managers into strip searches, starting with a February 2, 2003 Hinesville, Georgia case involving Tracy, Vanessa, and Sam.", "Javier Leyva ties that first case to a broader pattern the Courier-Journal tracked from 1992 to 2004, including Burger King, McDonald's, Applebee's, and Taco Bell incidents in North Dakota, Iowa, Alaska, and Kentucky.", "The Mount Washington, Kentucky tape on April 9, 2004 centers Louise, Donna Jean Summers, and Walter Nix, whose obedience lasts more than two and a half hours before the caller's demands overwhelm the office.", "Stanley Milgram's Yale shocks study, along with interviews from Wendy Wagner and Philip Zimbardo, is used to explain why people kept following a voice they thought was authority."]