How Did This Get Made? is a scripted-unscripted comedy panel show, not a traditional interview format, built around three recurring hosts — Paul Scheer, June Diane Raphael, and Jason Mantzoukas — who watch a chosen bad or strange movie and argue through its logic in real time. Most episodes follow a consistent structure: plot recap, character-by-character complaints, and a search for the film's 'best' or most inexplicable moment. A recurring subset of episodes are recorded live in front of audiences at venues like the Chicago Theater or festivals such as Bumbershoot, with crowd reactions folded into the discussion. A separate recurring segment, 'Last Looks,' is shorter and lighter, often hosted solo by Paul Scheer, and centers on listener-submitted corrections, fact-checks, and tangential media recommendations rather than a full film breakdown. The films covered skew toward cult, camp, and commercially unsuccessful titles from the 1980s through the 2000s, including romantic comedies, video-game adaptations, action thrillers, and dance movies. Episodes regularly include tangents into unrelated production trivia — casting near-misses, soundtrack credits, and behind-the-scenes anecdotes about directors and actors. The tone throughout is comedic and irreverent rather than analytical film criticism, with hosts frequently breaking into bits and callbacks. Listeners who enjoy genre riffing on bad movies, along with fans of the three hosts' broader comedy work, are the primary audience. Production is conversational and lightly edited, preserving cross-talk and live audience noise where applicable.