Wrestling history, one careful cup at a time.
Cup of Joe Wrestling Show treats pro wrestling history as lived memory, not trivia. Joey Harris moves between WWE event recaps, NXT match detail, memorial notes, and interviews with people who can place old names in context.
PRESS PLAY
Cup of Joe Wrestling Show is a long-running wrestling history podcast with a warm, careful, distinctly personal rhythm. Joey Harris works from Makeshift Studios in the shadow of South Central Virginia, but the show’s real home is the shared memory bank of pro wrestling fans. Some episodes are event reviews. Others are conversations. Both forms depend on patience, specificity, and the belief that the small details around a match often explain why the match mattered. A review of No Way Out 2009 does not just name the card; it places the show at Key Arena in Seattle, notes the attendance and buys, and then lets the matches take shape piece by piece. NXT TakeOver Dallas receives the same close attention, beginning with Tom Phillips and Corey Graves and moving into The Revival against American Alpha with the rhythm of an actual watch-along recap. Royal Rumble 2009 and Armageddon 2005 are handled as wrestling artifacts, full of entrances, commentary notes, angles, crowd context, and plainspoken reactions. The pace is not rushed. That is the point. The show also keeps one foot in wrestling’s older world, where names like Dennis Condry, Phil Hickerson, Norval Austin, Randy Rose, Bobby Eaton, Jim Cornette, Wild Bull Curry, and Flying Fred Curry carry history with them. Memorial notes are handled with direct respect rather than ceremony. The interview episodes broaden the archive. Mayor McCall talks wrestling podcast discovery and the way one show leads to another. Tony Richards brings conversations around Pro Wrestling Time Tunnel, Jim Barnett, Dory Funk senior, Amarillo wrestling, managers, announcers, and research. Brian Solomon discusses Guerrilla Monsoon through the lens of his book. Ed Holinsky brings memories connected to Vince McMahon’s national expansion, MTV, the Rock and Wrestling Connection, and WWF Magazine Marketing. These episodes are less about clean segments than about letting wrestling people talk long enough for the good side paths to appear. Cup of Joe Wrestling Show works best for fans who enjoy careful recaps, old names, territory context, and interviews where the question behind every question is how wrestling history gets remembered.
Made for: For pro wrestling fans who enjoy detailed event reviews, older territory references, WWE history, and conversational interviews with wrestling writers, historians, and podcasters.
What sets it apart: The show’s strength is its patient memory work: match-by-match recaps sit beside guest conversations, memorial notes, venue details, attendance figures, and the informal pathways by which wrestling history gets passed around.
Take your favorite beverage of choice and join Joey as he takes a look at the biggest shows on the WWE Network.
WWF boardroom lore meets a 5:10 title reign, saving you from choosing between history and havoc.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A measured Showdown review weighs the Hardy Boys' title win against the visible limits around it.
This Patreon preview frames NXT vs. TNA Showdown as a look at wrestling when nostalgia shares space with title stakes. Joey and Tyler spend much of the discussion on the Hardy Boys beating Dark State for the NXT Tag Team Championships, walking through the closing run from the…
Joey Harris and co-host Tyler dig into the SummerSlam cash-in, with Tyler's CM Punk skepticism giving the debate extra heat.
SummerSlam 2025 finds its cleanest hook in Seth Rollins' supposed right knee injury, then turns hard when he drops the crutches and brace, takes the briefcase from Paul Heyman, and cashes in after CM Punk beats Gunther.
A wrestling-history conversation about old names, hard roads, and the searches that may never be finished.
Joey Harris's conversation with Mayor McCall frames wrestling podcasting as a form of preservation. McCall talks about wrestlers he would still like to interview, including Billy Joe Travis and Troy Graham, and ties that wish to the harder parts of wrestling life: injuries,…
Joey Harris interviews former Pro Wrestling Illustrated editor Bob Smith about his career and podcasts.
Joey Harris talks with Ed Holinski, a former newsman who became the first editor of WWF Magazine and later worked in WWF marketing and merchandising.
Cup of Joe Wrestling Show episode 333 features Mayor McCall discussing the origins of Wrestling Talk with Mayor McCall and his focus on Memphis wrestling history.
Joey Harris reviews WWE's No Way Out 2009 pay-per-view event and pays tribute to recently deceased wrestling figures Rich Engling and Flying Fred Curry.
Joey Harris interviews Mayor McCall, host of Wrestling Talk, about his podcast and connections in the wrestling world.
Joey Harris reviews NXT TakeOver Dallas from 2016, focusing on the opening tag team championship match between The Revival and American Alpha.
Joey Harris reviews WWE Royal Rumble 2009 and pays tribute to wrestler Dennis Condry.
Joey Harris reviews the WWE Armageddon 2005 pay-per-view event, discussing the card and key matches.
Joey Harris interviews Ed Helinski about his career in wrestling marketing during Vince McMahon's national expansion.
Tony Richards explains why Jim Barnett mattered to Vince McMahon, Georgia, and Australia.
Joey Harris interviews Brian Solomon about his new biography of Gorilla Monsoon, discussing why the wrestler's story took so long to be told.
Ethan Page beats Mustafa Ali with the “twisted grin” after Ali’s mic cable gets caught near the announce desk.
Joey Harris and Patreon co-host Tyler review WWE SummerSlam 2025, a two-night event held August 2 and 3 at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey.
Joey Harris interviews Reggie Harp, known as Mr.
Joey Harris interviews Steve Gennarelli about his start as a wrestling fan in the early 1970s.