A journalist, a source, and a dangerous bond.
American Jihadi follows the strange, dangerous correspondence between Putzel and Omar Hammami, an Alabama-raised extremist hiding inside al-Shabaab’s world. The story moves through emails, calls, family interviews, news audio, and the grim question of what a journalist owes to a source who may also be a threat.
PRESS PLAY
American Jihadi is a grave, close-range investigation into Omar Hammami and the strange reporting relationship that formed around him. It begins with a premise that sounds almost impossible: an Alabama-raised man becomes entangled with al-Shabaab, then keeps communicating with a journalist while hiding, posturing, arguing, and fearing for his life. The show does not treat that contradiction as a puzzle to solve quickly. It sits with it. Putzel’s narration moves between calls, emails, family interviews, news audio, and fragments of Omar’s own self-mythology, letting the listener feel how messy the contact became. Omar is presented as familiar and frightening at once. He jokes about American culture, remembers music, demands attention, and then defends killing with ideological certainty. That split gives the series its central unease. The episodes trace his childhood in Alabama, his family’s religious conflicts, his public image, his online exchanges, and his eventual break with figures inside al-Shabaab. The reporting is often about danger, but also about ego. Omar wants to explain himself, control his image, and stay visible, even when visibility may put him at risk. Putzel wants the story and knows that wanting it has consequences. That tension is the show’s engine. The series also broadens beyond Omar’s voice, bringing in Shafiq, Deborah, Dina, J.M. Berger, Maroof, and others to show the human wreckage and political context around the case. It follows the shadow of violence from Somalia to the Westgate shopping mall attack in Nairobi, then back to Alabama, where family members and communities are left to live with what Omar became. The best moments are not clean revelations. They are uncomfortable pauses: a parent trying to explain a death, a journalist wondering whether access has become dependence, an analyst describing futility, a source reaching out from a tree after being shot. American Jihadi works because it refuses the easy version of the story. It is tense, reflective, and morally serious, with enough recorded texture to make the investigation feel unstable in the right way.
Made for: For listeners drawn to investigative true crime, extremism reporting, and morally complicated source relationships. It suits people who prefer patient narrative reconstruction over quick answers.
What sets it apart: The series stands apart by making the reporting relationship part of the story, not just a route into it. Omar’s emails, calls, family history, and public performance are weighed against the journalist’s own uncertainty.
American Jihadi is the incredible story of a complicated relationship between journalist Christof Putzel and Omar Hammami, the American-born Christian who became one of the FBI’s most wanted Islamic extremists. Follow the evolution of their risky relationship, dodging government surveillance to confide in one other—until it all came to an abrupt end. American Jihadi is hosted and Executive Produced by Christof Putzel in partnership with Endeavor Content. Executive Produced by Adam Levine, Josh Gummersall, and Adam Harrison at 222 Productions. To see how we use your data, visit https://www.endeavoraudio.com/privacy-policy.
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Close access and careful counterpoint turn one fraught reporter-source relationship into a precise study of radicalization, violence, and journalistic responsibility.
American Jihadi follows Christoph Putzel's sustained effort to understand how Omar Hammami moved from an Alabama adolescence into al-Shabaab in Somalia.
An Alabama childhood collides with Somalia, while you watch Christof Putzel test every easy explanation.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A close, tense report on Omar Hamami and the reporter who kept returning to him.
The episode gets its force from Omar Hamami's last email and the audio of him answering questions in his own voice before he disappears from the story. That material gives the piece its tension.
A tense portrait of one man split between familiar banter and armed conviction.
The episode follows Omar through two versions of himself: the joking email exchanges about 90s bands, and the harder vocabulary of Somalia, al-Shabaab, and sacrifice.
A family-forward portrait of Omar's story that makes the al-Shabaab frame feel personal.
American Jihadi treats Omar's autobiography as a family document as much as a story about al-Shabaab. It keeps circling back to Alabama, to the pier on the cover, and to the odd overlap between a documentary image from years earlier and the book Omar later made for himself.
A tense reporting chase that treats uncertainty as part of the story.
American Jihadi turns Omar Hammami into more than a neat headline. The episode stays with the reporting process itself, with Christoph Putzel trying to get a face-to-face conversation while Omar answers only through emails, clues, and warnings.
A careful hometown-to-war story that leaves room for doubt.
The episode starts with an Al Jazeera broadcast from 2007 and pulls it back into Daphne, Alabama, where people who knew Omar Hammami are left trying to square the boy they remember with the militant on screen.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
Patrick Radden Keefe investigates whether the CIA secretly wrote a Scorpions hit.
Jake Halpern and the Snowball team track a con artist who defrauded a family.
A city-by-city true-crime documentary, from Detroit's Kwame Kilpatrick scandal to mob confessions.
A murder rumor in rural Alabama unravels into a clockmaker's suicide and estate feud.
Elliot Wolfe introduces Dark Woods, a podcast about a body found in California redwoods.
The epilogue of American Jihadi traces the aftermath of Omar Hammami's death in Somalia — for his Alabama family, for the journalist who built a relationship with him, and for the communities around them.
Omar disappears.
Two Omars keep colliding.
A pier keeps pulling the story backward.
Omar Hamami stays a riddle.
In the fall of 2007, a scarf-covered American turns up in Somalia.