Altitude Crime

46 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Colorado true crime, case by case, evidence first.

The gist

Altitude Crime keeps its cases inside Colorado, where host Amelia Allen walks through searches, forensic evidence and arrests while crediting the reporting she draws on. The run includes the Boettcher kidnapping, Ted Bundy's Colorado cases, a DNA match taken from a discarded beer mug, and a full episode of updates on earlier cases.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Altitude Crime

Altitude Crime is a Colorado true crime podcast hosted by Amelia Allen, and the state line is its editorial filter. The closing credits name her as the person who wrote, recorded and edited each episode. The case list spans eras. She introduces 'The Kidnapping of Charles Boettcher II' by noting the show was overdue for a historic case, one she had first mentioned back in episodes one and two. The story involves kidnappers who released Charlie before collecting, a father who paid the ransom anyway with police in tow, and a money drop at a bridge north of Denver where officers watched the pickup, gave chase and lost the kidnappers. Other cases are far more recent. In the killing of Helene Pruszynski, a case reopened more than once without the eventual suspect ever surfacing, Douglas County deputies trail a man named Clanton in Lake Butler, north of Gainesville, until he leaves a beer mug behind, and a CBI test returns a match. Even the arrest has a twist: investigators approach him with a story about a securities fraud case and a stolen identity. 'Dating App Murders' takes up the death of Stacey, who worked for the nonprofit Partners Seeking a Cure. Her death was first listed as undetermined, and almost three years later her husband, Robert Feldman, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. The forensic detail can be stark. Recounting Gannon's case, Allen describes a Blue Star search that found blood evidence throughout the family home, alongside three weeks of canine, horseback and drone searches and a neighborhood that turned its lights blue, his favorite color. Ted Bundy gets more than one installment. 'Ted Bundy in Colorado - PART TWO' recounts a Clear Creek County investigator, Bob Denning, questioning Bundy about a victim named Shelly; Bundy admitted the killing and then refused to say more. Allen reads that refusal as a small win for Shelly, and asides like that are where her own sympathies show. Before getting into 'Therapists or Murderers - The Case of Candace Newmaker' she briefly leaves Colorado to comment on the Gabby Petito case, stressing that the evidence would have to tell that story. Sourcing stays visible. She credits 9 News reporting by name, posts sources on the show's website, and keeps a Suggest a Crime link there for proposed cases. Follow-up coverage gets a full episode too: 'The Update Episode' exists because the short updates she usually sends out kept growing, so it recaps several earlier cases and gives the episode number for each. Plugs for a Patreon tier with a bonus full-length episode and ad-free episodes frame the stories, along with warm thanks to the listeners she calls the 'crime clan'. What a listener gets is Colorado cases worked through searches, lab results and arrests, from one narrator who keeps track of where each case goes next.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime tied to real Colorado places like Denver, Douglas County and Clear Creek County, told by a single narrator who walks through searches, forensic evidence and arrests. It also fits someone who wants to hear what happened to a case after it was first covered.

What sets it apart: Its boundary is geographic rather than thematic, so the cases run from a historic ransom kidnapping and Ted Bundy's time in Colorado to arrests built on DNA and blood evidence. The host also credits news reporting by name and gives developing cases a full update episode that points back to where each was first covered.

In their own words

Live in Colorado? Learn more about true crime in your own backyard. Not a resident? Learn about some crimes you have never heard of!

Why you'd press play

A discarded beer mug becomes DNA evidence, just the sort of Colorado cold-case turn you came for.

Press play if you want

  • to follow an old case through the evidence that finally identifies a suspect
  • Colorado cases that take you from 1930s ransom kidnappings to dating-app murder investigations
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Colorado murder caseshistoric Colorado crimesTed Bundy in ColoradoDNA and forensic evidencekidnapping and ransommissing person searchesarrests in reopened casesupdates on previously covered cases

Talks about

Best episodes of Altitude Crime

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Episode 57 - The Update EpisodeMay 8, 2022

A candid case-update round-up that treats corrections and new evidence as part of responsible crime coverage.

Altitude Crime's Episode 57 lands as a practical update, with Amelia Allen first correcting an earlier mistake, then gathering developments from cases that reach back to Episode 7, including Crystal Reisinger. The episode's clearest strength is its respect for the record.

Episode 56 - Dating App MurdersMay 1, 2022

A dating-app thread connects two cases while evidence, motive, and safety advice share the frame.

Altitude Crime's "Episode 56 - Dating App Murders" looks at how dating apps can sit close to both intimacy and danger. Amelia Allen sets up two cases with different connections to app use: in one, an app links a killer and victim; in the other, dating-app activity becomes part…

Episode 55 -The Murder of Helene PruszynskiApr 24, 2022

A cold case moves from genetic genealogy to arrest, DNA evidence, and a recorded confession.

Altitude Crime follows the murder of Helene Pruszynski through the long path that eventually led investigators to Clanton, nearly 40 years after her disappearance, with genetic genealogy helping move the case from an old file to a named suspect.

Episode 54 - The Kidnapping of Charles Boettcher IIApr 17, 2022

A 1930s Colorado kidnapping story built around a tense ransom drop, a failed pursuit, and Vern Sankey's criminal past.

Altitude Crime places the kidnapping of Charles Boettcher II inside the ransom-kidnapping wave of the 1930s, then brings the focus back to Colorado with a case shaped by ransom pressure, police watching, and a risky handoff.

Podcasts like Altitude Crime

Episodes

  1. 1

    Altitude Crime Announcement

    May 14, 2022·3m
  2. 2

    Episode 57 - The Update Episode

    Hidden gem

    A burned-bone call near North Crestone campground on April 25, 2022 briefly raised fears about Crystal Reisinger and Suzanne Morphew, but the remains were returned to a family after being identified as cremains.

    May 8, 2022·29m·2 clips
  3. 3

    Episode 56 - Dating App Murders

    Hidden gem

    Amelia Allen's Altitude Crime episode "Episode 56 - Dating App Murders" connects Grindr and Tinder to two Colorado homicide cases, one in Colorado Springs and one in Denver.

    May 1, 2022·52m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Episode 55 -The Murder of Helene Pruszynski

    Hidden gem

    Altitude Crime episode 55 follows Helene Pruszynski's 1980 murder and the genetic-genealogy investigation that produced Colorado's first conviction in the case.

    Apr 24, 2022·32m·2 clips
  5. 5

    Episode 54 - The Kidnapping of Charles Boettcher II

    Hidden gem

    Charles Boettcher II was kidnapped from the garage at 777 Washington Street on February 12, 1933, and Anna Lou Boettcher was handed a $60,000 ransom note.

    Apr 17, 2022·33m·2 clips
  6. 6

    Episode 53 - Ted Bundy in Colorado - PART TWO

    Hidden gem

    Altitude Crime's "Episode 53 - Ted Bundy in Colorado - PART TWO" follows three Colorado-linked cases that remain unclosed: Melanie Suzanne Cooley, Shelly K.

    Apr 11, 2022·29m·1 clip
  7. 7

    Episode 52 - Ted Bundy in Colorado - PART ONE

    Apr 3, 2022·37m
  8. 8

    Episode 51 - The Murder of Aarone Thompson

    Mar 27, 2022·35m
  9. 9

    Episode 50 - The Murders of Mike Rust and Tim Watkins

    Mar 20, 2022·32m
  10. 10

    Episode 49 - The Murder of Rita Gutierrez-Garcia

    Mar 13, 2022·27m
  11. 11

    Episode 48 - The Kidnapping and Murder of Alie Berrelez

    Mar 6, 2022·28m
  12. 12

    Episode 47 - The Murder of Lacy Miller

    Feb 27, 2022·45m
  13. 13

    Episode 46 - The Norwood Doomsday Cult Murders

    Feb 20, 2022·34m
  14. 14

    Update 2.14.22 - Gannon Stauch

    Feb 15, 2022·4m
  15. 15

    Episode 45 - The Valentine’s Day Murders of Billy Trimbach, Stephanie Hart-Grizzell and Nick Kunselman

    Feb 13, 2022·32m
  16. 16

    Episode 44 - The Spider Man of Denver and The Murder of Nora Coursey

    Feb 6, 2022·26m
  17. 17

    Episode 43 - The Loomis Apartment Murders and The Beth Miller Case

    Jan 30, 2022·32m
  18. 18

    Update 1.29.22 - Gannon Stauch

    Jan 29, 2022·7m
  19. 19

    Episode 42 - The Unresolved Jonelle Matthews Case

    Jan 23, 2022·46m
  20. 20

    Episode 41 - The Massacre on Union Boulevard: The Gilbert Archibeque Killings

    Jan 16, 2022·34m
  21. 21

    Update 1.13.22 -Gannon Stauch

    Jan 14, 2022·3m
  22. 22

    Episode 40 - The Fatal Attraction Case: The Dianne Hood Case

    Jan 9, 2022·38m
  23. 23

    Episode 39 - The Murders of Alison Cantrell, Barbara Freyschlag and Polly Sullivan

    Jan 2, 2022·23m
  24. 24

    Episode 38 - The Ludlow Massacre - PART TWO

    Dec 19, 2021·35m
  25. 25

    Update 12.15.21 - Gannon Stauch

    Dec 16, 2021·4m
  26. 26

    Episode 37 - The Ludlow Massacre - PART ONE

    Dec 12, 2021·26m
  27. 27

    Episode 36 - The Murder of Kelsie Schelling

    Dec 5, 2021·33m
  28. 28

    Episode 35 - The Murder of Kathryn ”Kit” Grazioli

    Nov 28, 2021·38m
  29. 29

    Update 11.23.21 - Dylan Redwine

    Nov 24, 2021·7m
  30. 30

    Episode 34 - Kelsey Berreth - The Last Thanksgiving

    Nov 21, 2021·40m
  31. 31

    Episode 33 - 1911, The Road from Colorado Springs to the Villisca Ax Murder House

    Nov 14, 2021·29m
  32. 32

    Episode 32 - Guy Morton and the Creation of Families of Homicide Victims and Missing Persons

    Nov 7, 2021·17m
  33. 33

    Update 11.4.21 - Gannon Stauch

    Nov 5, 2021·2m
  34. 34

    Episode 31 - Halloween in Windsor - The Sorenson Murders

    Oct 31, 2021·16m
  35. 35

    Episode 30 - Domestic Violence Awareness Month - Jose Sanchez and Riley Johnson

    Oct 24, 2021·14m
  36. 36

    Episode 29 - Domestic Violence Awareness Month - Mandy Folsom

    Oct 17, 2021·14m
  37. 37

    Update - Mark Redwine Sentencing

    Oct 15, 2021·3m
  38. 38

    Episode 28 - Domestic Violence Awareness Month - Sarah Beasley, John Salazar and The Johnson Family

    Oct 10, 2021·27m
  39. 39

    Episode 27 - Domestic Violence Awareness Month - Edgar Olivas

    Oct 3, 2021·13m
  40. 40

    Episode 26 - Therapists or Murderers - The Case of Candace Newmaker

    The host celebrates the podcast's six-month milestone and briefly discusses the Gabby Petito case before diving into the main episode.

    Sep 26, 2021·38m
  41. 41

    Episode 25 - The Murder of Gannon Stauch

    Host Amelia Allen introduces the murder case of 11-year-old Gannon Stock, covering the preliminary hearing of his stepmother Letitia Stock and the chronological evidence.

    Sep 19, 2021·35m
  42. 42

    Episode 24 - A Cold Case I Can Tell an Ending To - Jennifer Watkins

    Sep 12, 2021·16m
  43. 43

    Episode 23 - An Unbelievable Crime - PART TWO

    Sep 5, 2021·38m
  44. 44

    Episode 22 - An Unbelievable Crime - PART ONE

    Host Amelia Allen introduces a Colorado true crime podcast, promotes a YouTuber, and leads a moment of silence for Afghanistan fatalities.

    Aug 29, 2021·36m
  45. 45

    Episode 21 - The Greeley Mall Murder of Kayleah Wilson

    Host Amelia Allen introduces a listener-requested case about 12-year-old Kalia Wilson who disappeared in Greeley, Colorado in 2010.

    Aug 22, 2021·33m
  46. 46

    Episode 20 - Missing Person - Christopher Abeyta

    Aug 15, 2021·41m