Who the Hell is Hamish? · The Australian

From The Front: Hedley Thomas’ new cold case podcast, 'Bronwyn'

·21 min·2 clips

For five years after Bronwyn vanished, police didn't take a single formal statement from anyone.

This episode of The Front previews Hedley Thomas's new investigative podcast, "Bronwyn," which re-examines the 1991 disappearance of young mother Bronwyn Winfield from Lennox Head, New South Wales. Host Clare Harvey interviews Thomas, the award-winning journalist behind "The Teacher's Pet," who explains how this cold case came to his attention. Thomas first heard Bronwyn's name in late 2017 from former deputy state coroner Carl Milovanovich, who had overseen a 2002 inquest into her disappearance. Milovanovich had expressed grave concerns about several cases of missing women from the 80s and 90s, where police often dismissed foul play. Bronwyn Winfield was 31, a devoted mother to daughters aged five and ten, and had recently separated from her husband, John, a bricklayer who built their family home. She vanished on a Sunday night after John returned from working in Sydney, having just moved back into the marital home with her children for two nights. John's account states Bronwyn left in an unknown car after a disagreement, but she had made plans for the next day and left behind almost all her belongings. Her eldest daughter, Crystal, reported hearing raised voices before the children were woken late that night and driven to Sydney by their father. John Winfield waited 11 days before reporting his wife missing, after pressure from Bronwyn's brother, Andy, and her close friend Deb Hall. The initial police investigation was shockingly poor, failing to take formal statements or properly search the property, partly due to a bias linking Bronwyn's disappearance to her own mother's history of leaving the family. In 2002, Coroner Milovanovich formally found Bronwyn dead and recommended John Winfield be charged with her murder, but the Director of Public Prosecutions, Nicholas Cowdery, declined due to insufficient evidence. Thomas notes that John Winfield, when contacted, stood by his answers to 415 police questions and suggested Bronwyn's family had a "history of mental illness," a claim contradicted by friends and witness statements. A surprising insight is the systemic failure in policing that Thomas identifies, where the disappearances of young mothers during marital breakdowns were routinely filed as missing persons cases rather than potential homicides. The most baffling element for the family is the DPP's decision not to prosecute despite the coroner's recommendation, highlighting an opaque and often disconnected legal process. Thomas finds it implausible that Bronwyn chose to vanish, given her devotion to her daughters and lack of resources, firmly believing she was met with foul play. The episode's tone is journalistic and explanatory, focusing on the historical context and investigative process rather than sensationalism. It is conversational, with Harvey prompting Thomas to detail the case's chronology and legal hurdles. Listeners who enjoyed "The Teacher's Pet" or true crime investigations into institutional failures will find this preview compelling. Those seeking a resolved narrative or conclusive answers may be frustrated, as the case remains officially unsolved.

As heard by us

A careful cold-case setup that keeps the mystery grounded in real reporting.

Bronwyn plays like a cold-case opening move rather than a full excavation. Clare Harvey introduces The Australian's new investigative podcast from Hedley Thomas, returning to the territory that made The Teacher's Pet a major story.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a sober first look at Bronwyn Winfield's disappearance on The Front.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Who the Hell is Hamish?