Unfinished Justice: Inside the NYPD Cold Case Squad · Asterlight

What It's Really Like Working in the Cold Case Squad

·27 min·1 clip

Cold case units have shrunk from 50 detectives to just 6-7 because solving old murders doesn't prevent new ones.

Crystal Genesis opens the season finale with Wendell Stratford and Vito Spano. Their careers are laid out clearly, with Stratford traced from NYPD cop in 1984 to detective in 1990 and retirement in September 2021, and Spano described as the host who has guided the series. Genesis adds her own perspective as someone who moved from London a year earlier and is still getting to know the city. The show has the feel of a final pass before the credits. The conversation then turns to exceptional clearance. Spano says he did not know the term before the podcast and explains that a case can be cleared without the perpetrator being physically put in prison when the offender is dead or otherwise confirmed but not accessible. He is direct about his discomfort, saying he wants the person in jail and the victim’s family to have their day in court. That objection gives the discussion its emotional center. John Belahunas is brought in as a critical voice from Southeastern Louisiana University. He says exceptional clearance has historically been reserved for extremely rare cases where an offender is dead or in jail. Stratford pushes back. He says academics tend to look at the issue through an academic lens, while detectives have to work from the investigative and law-enforcement side. He calls exceptional clearance an excellent tool, but not a casual one. The episode lays out the safeguards in sequence. Stratford says it requires lengthy supporting documents from the detective and the commanding officer. He says the paperwork goes to district attorney review, and an assistant district attorney in the homicide bureau is assigned to it. The point is that the process is meant to be strict, documented, and reviewed. The finale closes with thanks, acknowledgments, and credits for the series.

As heard by us

A procedural finale that treats closure as a legal question, not a neat emotional ending.

The season finale turns an exceptional clearance into a plainspoken argument about what closure can and cannot be. Crystal Genesis brings Wendell Stratford and Vito Spano into the same frame, and the best passages sit in the strain between Spano's frustration and Stratford's…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Hear how cold-case work turns on paperwork, not just breakthroughs.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Unfinished Justice: Inside the NYPD Cold Case Squad