Mike describes three figures with egg-like faces and no eyes or mouth standing across the creek.
The episode features multiple true scary stories set at summer camps, narrated by Uncle Josh. It opens with a story from Mike, who recounts his experience as a teenager in the late 1980s at a Boy Scout camp. Mike and his patrol, the Wolf Patrol, set up a secluded campsite by a creek. On the third night, they see three figures across the creek, described as wearing strange headdresses and later having egg-like faces with no features. The figures appear and vanish multiple times, culminating in a tall, dark figure appearing right at their campsite. The patrol never reports it, fearing they'd lose their independence. The second story involves Camp Timberlake in Washington, where campers report large hairy men and huge footprints, leading to the camp closing early; this is linked to Bigfoot lore. A third story from Camp Howard in Oregon describes four boys skinny-dipping and seeing a shadowy figure with reflective eyes; their counselor reveals this figure has been seen since the 1960s. Other stories include a premonition dream about a grandfather's death, a sex offender shining a torch into tents, an archery accident, a hermit stealing from a campsite, a possible suicide at a beach, creepy men at a window, a serial child abuser counselor, and a drowning in a lake with caves. The episode ends with Uncle Josh encouraging listeners to submit their own stories.
