True Crime Obsessed · True Crime Obsessed

New York Homicide: Broken Pride (S1E5)

September 11, 2025·46 min·4 clips

Amanda, the survivor, becomes the prime suspect in her girlfriend's murder, shocking the community.

The episode centers on the July 5th, 1995 attack on Amanda Leach and Sylvia Lugo at their Brooklyn apartment, which detectives from the 84th Precinct were called to in the early hours after the 4th of July. Amanda reported that an unknown Latino male forced his way in, raped her, and shot Sylvia twice in the head before fleeing with a rental car. Sylvia died from her injuries; Amanda survived a gunshot wound to the leg. Hosts Jillian Bezzavalli and Patrick Hines provide running commentary on the New York Homicide documentary series as they break down how investigators quickly grew skeptical of Amanda's account. The medical examiner determined that either of Sylvia's head wounds would have been immediately incapacitating, contradicting Amanda's claim that Sylvia stood up and was shot a second time. The angle of Amanda's leg wound was deemed consistent with self-infliction, and the sexual assault evidence kit returned inconclusive results. Police also discovered their stolen rental car two blocks from the apartment of Trillane McKinney, Amanda's ex-girlfriend, who had publicly threatened to kill Sylvia during a softball game months earlier. The LGBTQ community in Park Slope rallied around Amanda, pointing out that a serial rapist known as the Park Slope Rapist was still at large in the neighborhood. Hosts critique the investigation for the way it appeared to prioritize the lesbian relationship angle over the active serial rapist lead, and note the racial dimension in that Amanda is Black. They also discuss the tight-knit lesbian softball community in Park Slope, where many of the key figures knew one another. Throughout, they blend genuine engagement with the case details with their comedic on-air dynamic. The tone is an enthusiastic recap-with-commentary format, mixing dark crime material with the hosts' humor about lesbian culture and community solidarity. The episode is well-suited to true crime fans who follow the documentary genre and listeners interested in cases involving LGBTQ victims and how law enforcement handled them in the 1990s.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime Obsessed