Stephen Marshall

·59 min·5 clips

A severed head missing its face is found in a field, haunting investigators in the Jigsaw Man case.

In this section, the case keeps drifting back to Jeffrey's apartment. Police begin with Stephen Marshall and Sarah Bush because they were still tied to the place after Jeffrey was gone. Fair starting point. The hosts talk through why investigators would look at the people still nearby first, especially when rent and whereabouts already sound messy. Stephen does not exactly settle anyone down during questioning. The arresting officer remembers him as very nervous and jittery, leg shaking, which sends the hosts into a grounded aside about what police interviews can do to people. Sarah sounds uneasy too. Her line about Stephen's mood swings, and how he could be "really evil," does not get brushed off as routine relationship anger. It hangs there. The hosts point out that people do not usually reach for wording like that unless they are trying to warn you about something. Stephen gives no comment. Then the episode moves from bad vibes to evidence. Blood turns up in several places: the bedroom, the bathroom, under the carpet, and Jeffrey's recovered car. That keeps the case close to the apartment. The fiber match is ugly. Green fibers from a shirt in Stephen's room match fibers found on duct tape used to wrap the dismembered remains. The hosts stay blunt without getting lurid, walking through what each piece suggests. Near the end, a listener point opens up a bigger thought about trials and how jurors may hear only part of the story.

As heard by us

A grim case told plainly, with interviews and forensic detail steadily closing in.

Stephen Marshall is framed as a case that moves through police interviews and a forensic trail that keeps circling back to the apartment. Mike and Gibby stay focused on Marshall, Sarah Bush, and the strain in their relationship, including her account of his mood swings and her…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a case that tightens from suspicion into hard forensic proof?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from True Crime All The Time