“To suffer or permit to work”

February 17, 2021·48 min·3 clips

JanPro's founder admits his cleaning company isn't actually in the cleaning business — and that claim is now a legal strategy.

The tape starts with a call. The host is trying to reach Jack LaPointe, the founder of JanPro and the person behind the business model tied to Jerry Vasquez's janitorial franchise. At first, it is just a bad connection, a recording request, and a scheduling snag. Pretty ordinary stuff, until it opens onto the bigger fight over what counts as work. Jerry says he was exploited. JanPro said he was an independent contractor. The episode sits in that gap and shows how a label can change what someone is owed. Richard Carlson then steps in with the legal frame. The employment law professor explains that minimum wage protections can treat a worker as an employee unless the hiring party can prove real independent business status. His plumber example does useful work here. It separates occasional independent work from arrangements that may look independent but run more like employment. Carlson says the law's broad language was deliberate. Lawmakers had already watched mass production, assembly lines, and the tail end of the Industrial Revolution remake work in the 1930s, so they wrote for change. The episode then brings that old argument into the present with Uber, Lyft, and DoorDash. The same pitch comes back: new technology has supposedly made older worker protections outdated. That word gets a hard look. When Uber's CEO talks about the traditional view of one full-time job with one company, and a lobbying group calls for modernized workforce policy, outdated becomes more than a description. It nudges minimum wage law and employee status into the past, even though they were written to handle recurring reinventions of labor. The ending does not slam the door. The next chapter turns to people who helped popularize the non-employee workforce and still argue that companies should consider it as a strategy.

As heard by us

A janitorial franchise dispute becomes a clear lesson in how labor law defines work.

Chapter three of The Uncertain Hour tracks a janitorial franchise dispute from a single phone call into the legal rules that decide who counts as a worker.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a sharp look at who work law protects, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Uncertain Hour