The Toolshed: A Fantasy Baseball Podcast · Eric Cross

EP 427 | 2026 Catcher Dynasty Rankings

·55 min·5 clips

Eric Cross and James Anderson dive into why catcher is their favorite position to rank in dynasty fantasy baseball.

Eric Cross hosts this episode of The Toolshed, joined by guest James Anderson, the lead prospect analyst at Rotowire. They are continuing a series of dynasty rankings by focusing specifically on the catcher position for the 2026 season. Both hosts express that catcher is a surprisingly enjoyable position for them to analyze despite its traditional lack of glamour. The episode presents their individual top 30 dynasty rankings for catchers, covering both major league players and prospects. They discuss the rising talent level at the position, noting significant contributions from young players who have already debuted. The conversation also includes analysis of promising catchers still developing in the minor leagues. A key insight is their shared view that the catcher position is undergoing a positive transformation with an influx of young talent. They contrast catcher with traditionally "sexy" positions like outfield, pitcher, and shortstop. The hosts plan to break down their rankings in detail, discussing specific players and their long-term fantasy value. The tone is collaborative and expert-driven, with both hosts bringing established analytical credentials to the discussion. The style is conversational and deeply focused on fantasy baseball strategy and player evaluation. This episode is ideal for dynasty fantasy baseball managers seeking detailed catcher rankings and prospect analysis. Listeners who only play redraft leagues or have no interest in the catcher position might find the deep dive too specialized.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Toolshed: A Fantasy Baseball Podcast