The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman · NYPost

Keith Hernandez Believes Mets MUST Re-Sign Pete Alonso & Edwin Diaz + Blue Jays Bounce Back From 18-Inning Classic

·53 min·3 clips

Keith Hernandez says the Mets "got to sign Diaz too" and keep Alonso because the replacement options are thin.

1. The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman centers this episode on the World Series and Keith Hernandez's view of the Mets' offseason. 2. Joel Sherman and Jon Heyman host from Los Angeles, while Keith Hernandez joins as a former Mets first baseman and current Mets analyst. 3. The episode asks whether Toronto can finish the World Series and whether the Mets can recover from a disappointing season. 4. Sherman and Heyman say the Dodgers were heavy favorites, but Toronto entered Game 5 tied 2-2 and playing with resilience. 5. They cite Toronto's 94 wins, its 34-19 division-series margin over the Yankees, and its comeback from 2-0 and 3-2 deficits against Seattle. 6. They discuss George Springer missing Game 4 and John Heyman's observation that Bo Bichette looked limited running. 7. The hosts revisit the 18-inning game at Dodger Stadium and Freddie Freeman's walk-off homer after an exhausting night. 8. They note that Toronto's stars and complementary players, including Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Chris Bassett, and Addison Barger, have carried major postseason weight. 9. Joel Sherman highlights Bassett's relief work and Barger's strong arm, hard contact, and unusual route to becoming a major leaguer. 10. Jon Heyman says the Blue Jays' front office came into the year under pressure, but complimentary players have outperformed expectations in October. 11. Keith Hernandez calls the Mets' season "terrible" and says it was more disappointing than some earlier collapses because expectations were so high. 12. He points to injuries to Kodai Senga and Sean Manaea, plus Clay Holmes' workload after moving out of the ninth inning, as major issues. 13. Hernandez also cites the Mets' defensive mistakes, including errors and picked-off runners, as signs that the team was not playing clean baseball. 14. He says the Mets hit only .218 with runners in scoring position in July before improving over the final two months. 15. Hernandez rejects the word "regret" for 1980s Mets teams and says the 2025 Mets should feel disappointed because they failed to make the playoffs. 16. He says Francisco Lindor is vocal and gregarious, while Juan Soto is serious and keeps to himself, and he compares Soto's personality to Mookie Wilson's. 17. Hernandez says Pete Alonso is a right-handed bat the Mets cannot easily replace, calling him "the second coming of Harmon Killebrew." 18. He also says the Mets "got to sign Diaz too," and he describes his own first-base mechanics when explaining Alonso's throwing issues. 19. The conversation is baseball-heavy, opinionated, and built around long-form back-and-forth between the hosts and Hernandez. 20. Fans of Mets roster decisions, World Series analysis, and Keith Hernandez commentary should listen; casual listeners seeking general sports chatter may skip.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Show: A NY Post baseball podcast with Joel Sherman & Jon Heyman