Nineteen Eighty-Four: Dominic Sandbrook on Big Brother, Surveillance, and Fear (The Book Club)

·24 min·2 clips

Dominic Sandbrook reveals how Trump's relentless lies mirror Orwell's concept of forcing people to believe two plus two equals five.

1. The Rest Is Politics presents a crossover interview in which host Alastair Campbell speaks with historian Dominic Sandbrook about Orwell's 1984 and its contemporary relevance. 2. Dominic Sandbrook is a co-host of The Rest Is History and author of multiple books on British history; producer Tabitha Syrett co-hosts the Book Club show with him. 3. The episode's core question is whether Orwell's 1984 — written as a warning about Stalinist totalitarianism — functions as a prophecy for the Trump era and modern surveillance culture. 4. Campbell says he first read 1984 in 1974 and that watching Trump's administration made him think of Big Brother — particularly ICE enforcement and Trump's use of social media to push statements everyone in the room knows are false. 5. Sandbrook identifies 'doublethink' — holding two contradictory ideas simultaneously and forcing oneself to believe the false one — as the concept from 1984 most visible in contemporary MAGA politics. 6. As a specific example, Campbell recounts Trump posting 'I'm glad he's dead' immediately after Robert Mueller's death, and then observing every Republican spokesperson struggling to defend the statement in television interviews. 7. Sandbrook draws a direct line from Stalin's 1930s show trials — where Old Bolsheviks confessed to crimes they had not committed — through Putin's 'nothing is true and anything is possible' doctrine to Trump's political ecosystem. 8. Campbell references 'Nothing Is True and Everything Is Possible,' a book about how Putin remade modern Russia, as a bridge between Orwell's fictional world and today's geopolitics. 9. Sandbrook argues that Berlusconi was an early architect of this culture because he understood that controlling media and football — he owned one of Italy's biggest clubs — converts directly into political power. 10. The conversation turns to whether figures like Marco Rubio and JD Vance actually believe what they say publicly, or whether the cameras-off version involves private cynicism; Sandbrook says he does not believe Rubio believes his current positions. 11. Campbell draws on his government experience to argue that Tony Blair's leadership was defensible precisely because Blair actively welcomed internal challenge, contrasting this with Trump, Putin, Erdogan, and Modi, who he says deliberately construct echo chambers. 12. Sandbrook raises the BBC's Orwell statue outside Broadcasting House, which carries the inscription: 'If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.' 13. Campbell argues that mainstream media, including the BBC, failed during Brexit by telling audiences what they wanted to hear rather than what they needed to hear. 14. In the Book Club clip, Sandbrook describes Winston Smith's acts of micro-rebellion: buying an antique journal to keep private thoughts, purchasing an amber paperweight from a pre-revolutionary era, and beginning an illicit affair with a colleague named Julia. 15. Winston and Julia become involved with a colleague called O'Brien, whom they believe is part of a resistance group called the Brotherhood — this ends badly, as Sandbrook notes with a spoiler alert. 16. Sandbrook describes 1984 as simultaneously a dystopian political warning, a doomed love story, a horror story, a work of science fiction, and 'a reflection on the importance of history,' but argues it works first as a gripping page-turner. 17. Tabitha Syrett (in the Book Club clip) says she does not like 1984 despite admiring it, and describes it as a 'boy book'; a 2014 YouGov poll confirmed men are significantly more likely to have read it than women. 18. Orwell's biography, as discussed in the Book Club clip, reveals he was born Eric Arthur Blair in Bengal in 1903, educated at Eton where Aldous Huxley taught him French, and served in the Burmese imperial police before returning to England to write. 19. The episode will appeal to listeners interested in political theory, 20th-century history, and the question of how authoritarian systems reshape truth. 20. Listeners who prefer lighter political commentary or who have already heard extensive Trump-Orwell comparisons may find the ground familiar.

As heard by us

A brisk, historically minded take on 1984 that keeps Orwell feeling immediate.

Dominic Sandbrook and Alastair Campbell use Orwell's 1984 as a way into surveillance, fear, and the habits power falls into when no one is looking.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

George Orwell's 1984, total surveillance, and a political conversation that still feels relevant.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Rest Is Politics