Port Vale Heroics, Magical Max & Arsenal’s Unfair Criticism

March 9, 2026·49 min·3 clips

Shearer and Richardson push back hard on Arsenal criticism after the club becomes the first Premier League team to 100 goals in all competitions.

Port Vale catches them cold. The first stretch is all FA Cup weekend, with Sunderland giving the room a pleased little charge. Gary has fun with the workload chat. Alan has been busy, Micah takes the hit for only doing Wrexham-Chelsea, and it feels more like a post-match table than a polished studio segment. Then Max Dalman gets them leaning in. The praise is simple and physical: how he moves past players, the first touch, the way a player can make everyone sit up without much explanation. João Pedro brings out the familiar "called it early" routine, until someone points out that spotting a good player there was not exactly sorcery. Arsenal is where the episode tightens. The panel push back on the steady complaints about style, set pieces, own goals, and whether the football always looks convincing. The numbers make the moaning harder to sell: 100 goals in all competitions, top of the Champions League group, into the FA Cup quarter-final, seven points clear in the Premier League. One voice is done with it. From that view, Arsenal are flying, and the search for another flaw starts to feel like complaint hunting. The caveat still matters. They have not won anything yet, so the praise is about where they are, not what is already in the cabinet. That is the useful bit. Arsenal can look extraordinary in results and still be open to real football criticism when the performances feel less dominant. The mood turns more uneasy near the end. West Ham and Forest at least look like they are fighting. Spurs worry them because that fight is harder to spot. Then it ends quickly, as this show often does: laugh, argue, qualify, move on.

As heard by us

FA Cup shocks, Arsenal talk, and praise for Max Dalman and Joao Pedro.

FA Cup weekend sets the tone, with Port Vale's shock over Sunderland drawing a quick reaction before the talk moves to Arsenal and a firm pushback against the urge to nitpick.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Port Vale's upset over Sunderland, Arsenal debate, and sharp player chatter from a busy FA Cup Sunday.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Rest Is Football