The Panpsycast Philosophy Podcast · Jack Symes | Andrew Horton, Oliver Marley, Rose de Castellane, Gregory Mill

Episode 141, 'Deadly Sins' with Elizabeth Oldfield (Part II - Further Analysis and Discussion)

April 6, 2025·39 min·3 clips

Elizabeth Oldfield reveals why individual meaning is an illusion and why loneliness stems from our myth of self-creation.

Part two begins with the book's spiritual pull. Oldfield is asked how plural societies can give people plenty and still fail to offer steady sources of communal meaning. Her answer starts with anthropology. People are not just individuals; persons come alive through relationship and communion. She translates that Christian frame with care. It can be heard in secular terms, though the conversation keeps catching the places where spirituality is still in the room. The sins stay close to that problem: moral life keeps pointing back to the kind of communal meaning modern societies can, or cannot, provide. Then Jack changes the pressure. He recalls the Between God and Atheism event with Rowan Williams, Alex O'Connor, Philip Goff, and Oldfield. The question is pointed without getting showy. Oldfield had written candidly about being the only woman on panels, and the conversation follows that unease into public philosophy itself. She is still working it out. The harder issue is whether debate formats, status games, and performance styles carry centuries of male-coded expectations. Her answer is provisional, not slippery. She describes the private conversation after the event as a gracious space where years of panel discomfort could finally be named. The language turns almost funny, then serious. A passing point about Hollywood ratios helps name a wider pattern without pretending it is tidy. The close returns to friendship and virtue. Even the joke about needing help moving becomes a neat little test: if friendship shows itself in need, what happens when need never shows up?

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Panpsycast Philosophy Podcast