Bills FIRE McDermott & Broncos Scramble to Replace Nix

·52 min·4 clips

Sean McDermott didn't see his firing coming, and the Bills now face a once-in-a-lifetime chance to coach Josh Allen.

Hosts Conor Orr and Albert Breer analyze the sudden firing of Bills head coach Sean McDermott and the Broncos' playoff quarterback crisis. They frame this as a pivotal moment in the NFL's coaching carousel with major implications for two franchises. The Buffalo Bills' head coaching vacancy is immediately highlighted as a top-tier job because it offers the chance to coach superstar quarterback Josh Allen. Sean McDermott's dismissal reportedly surprised him, though internal pressure had been building for months, spilling over after the team's playoff loss. The hosts note McDermott's impressive career record, ranking 15th all-time in winning percentage and third among active coaches. Buffalo's front office is urged to exhaust all options, including pursuing sitting head coaches like the Rams' Sean McVay or the 49ers' Kyle Shanahan, despite the unlikelihood of a move. Prominent candidates mentioned for the Bills job include Colts coach Shane Steichen, former Bills teammate and current hot assistant Davis Webb, and offensive coordinators like Brian Daboll or Kliff Kingsbury. An interesting theory posits that mobile quarterbacks like Josh Allen see their mechanics degrade late in seasons due to accumulated hits, affecting playoff precision. The Bills' general manager, Brandon Beane, is seen as a dominant personality who could mentor a younger, first-time head coach hire. For McDermott, potential landing spots include the Tennessee Titans or Arizona Cardinals, with Arizona resembling his early Bills teams. The conversation contrasts how perception often outweighs similar records, comparing Sean Payton's market value to Mike McCarthy's. The Broncos' situation centers on quarterback Bo Nix being lost for the playoffs with a broken ankle, forcing backup Jared Stidham into action. Stidham, who has a strong relationship with Sean Payton and a $12 million contract, is seen as a capable but unproven replacement. The hosts debate whether Stidham can replicate Nix's clutch performance in high-pressure moments, a key trait that made Nix a first-round pick. A parallel is drawn to Jeff Hostetler leading the Giants to a Super Bowl win as a backup, suggesting a potential Cinderella story for Payton and Stidham. The tone is fast-paced, insider-driven, and conversational, mirroring two reporters scrambling to break down a major news story. They blend reported facts with speculative scenarios and personal anecdotes, like Orr's story about covering a hurricane in a garbage bag poncho. This episode is perfect for NFL fans who crave immediate, behind-the-scenes analysis of coaching moves and quarterback dramas. Listeners who prefer structured game breakdowns or dislike speculative "what-if" scenarios might find the rapid-fire delivery overwhelming.

As heard by us

A Bills coaching change turns into a sharp look at value, pressure, and perception.

Conor and Albert spend the episode on the Bills' decision to let Sean McDermott go, with Josh Allen sitting at the center of why Buffalo still looks like one of the league's better jobs.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the McDermott firing and the coaching carousel sorted without losing the league context.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The MMQB NFL Podcast