The Life Planning 101 Podcast · Angela Robinson

The Insurance Insider

April 8, 2026·42 min·3 clips

A widow thanked the driver who killed her husband for having enough insurance to support her family.

1. Life Planning 101 host Jim interviews Rodney Schultz, who has taught insurance licensing courses in Wisconsin for 42 to 43 years and written the textbooks used in those courses. 2. Rodney Schultz holds deep credentials in insurance education: he obtained a degree in education specifically to teach, has written insurance licensing textbooks, served as president of the Wisconsin chapter of the National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, and teaches via Zoom across multiple technical college campuses including New Richmond, Superior, Ashland, and Rice Lake. 3. The episode's central thesis is that consumers make a costly mistake by shopping for insurance primarily on price, because 800-number and online insurers systematically reduce coverage limits—rather than service overhead—to lower premiums. 4. Rodney describes personally calling three or four major 800-number insurers: each quoted back his existing 250/500/100 liability limits on bodily injury but simultaneously set his uninsured motorist coverage to the Wisconsin state minimum of 25,000 per person and 50,000 per accident, and pre-checked 'declined' for underinsured motorist coverage without asking him. 5. He explains what each coverage actually does: uninsured motorist pays the policyholder's bodily injury when the at-fault driver has no insurance; underinsured motorist pays when the at-fault driver has coverage but not enough to cover the losses. 6. Rodney notes that a 30-year-old who earns $50,000 per year and is killed has an immediate human life value of approximately $1.5 million in lost future income alone—before health-related expenses, lost wages, and property damage are added—making state-minimum coverage of 25,000 per person catastrophically inadequate. 7. Jim explains umbrella insurance: it adds liability coverage above all underlying policies—auto, home, boat, ATV—and his experience puts the cost at roughly $100 per year for the first $1 million and $125 per year for each additional million. 8. Rodney discloses that he carries a $3 million umbrella policy for $475 per year ($40/month), compared to a quote of $1,490/year from an 800-number provider—illustrating the value of an agent relationship for this specific product. 9. Umbrella policies require minimum underlying liability of at least 100/300/100, and most companies require 250/500/100 before they will issue one; Rodney states that the wrongful death payout for an adult in Wisconsin is $350,000 immediately, which would exhaust a 250/500 policy and require umbrella coverage for the remainder. 10. Rodney uses his classroom story about a widow who wrote a personal letter to the driver who accidentally killed her husband: she thanked him specifically for having the right amount of insurance, because it was the only way her family could pay their mortgage and raise their children after losing a breadwinner. 11. The two-question classroom exercise: ask insurance students how much they would sue for if a driver killed their spouse on the highway—answers range from $1 million to $5 million—then ask how much life insurance they carry on that same spouse; most say $50,000, $150,000, or nothing, and visibly recoil at the inconsistency. 12. Jim frames the 4% withdrawal rate rule as the foundation of life insurance sizing: a person earning $100,000 needs roughly $2.5 million in coverage (25x income) to replace their income stream at a 4% withdrawal rate—before accounting for employer-provided health insurance (approximately $800/month) and 401k contributions. 13. Rodney explains why insurance premiums have been rising 35–45% in recent years: at least one major insurer loses $1.04 for every dollar of premium collected, surviving only because investment income offsets underwriting losses; in 2022 and 2023, one large California insurer paid out $6 billion per year in losses. 14. Post-COVID inflation has structurally raised claim costs: auto shop technician labor rates rose from approximately $50/hour to $150/hour; composite deck boards rose from $37 to $137 per board during the pandemic, settling around $90 a year later; and electronic vehicle components are disproportionately expensive to repair. 15. Jim adds that a 2012 Volkswagen Touareg he owned was deemed a total loss by the insurance company after a deer collision—the insurer valued it at $15,000; he kept the car for $3,000 less but found the $1,600 headlight repair estimate ballooned due to labor cost inflation. 16. Rodney recommends annual policy reviews and notes that most 800-number and large-volume insurers do not proactively offer them—leaving policyholders underinsured as home values and labor costs rise without corresponding coverage increases. 17. A practical cost-management strategy from Jim: shift to higher deductibles (e.g., $2,500 instead of $250 on collision) to reduce premiums while maintaining umbrella coverage for the catastrophic risks that cannot be written out of pocket—and deposit the premium difference into a dedicated deductible savings account. 18. The episode is a conversational interview between Jim and Rodney, with a warm register—they discuss teaching philosophy, Zoom classroom management, a dog throwing up during class, and Wisconsin winter driving. 19. Consumers who have not reviewed their insurance policies in more than a year, or who have switched to 800-number providers for the price savings, will find this episode most directly applicable. 20. Listeners looking for investment strategy or financial planning beyond the insurance domain will need to look to other Life Planning 101 episodes.

As heard by us

Insurance looks cheaper until the missing coverage becomes the expensive part.

Rodney Schultz treats insurance as a practical habit, not a product pitch. The episode stays grounded in ordinary choices: annual policy reviews, umbrella coverage, wage garnishment, and the gap between a lower premium and real protection. Its main point is plain enough.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

The cheapest policy can be the priciest mistake.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Life Planning 101 Podcast