playnext.fm

The Inquiry · BBC World Service

Why is basic income being debated?

March 31, 2026·24 min·1 clip
Nobel economist Daron Acemoglu warns UBI would create a two-tier dystopia of 'underclass' and 'high-status producers.'
Why is basic income being debated? The host begins at an October 2025 Irish government media conference after the 2026 budget announcement, where a basic income pilot for artists is made permanent. The numbers are clear: €18 million, or US$22 million, for regular no-conditions cash support to 2,000 artists. Ireland gives the episode its starting point. From there, basic income becomes a wider international argument, tested and promoted in different ways. Security is the first frame. A guest warns that the schemes vary too much for easy generalisations, even though public attention has grown. Inequality is part of the pressure. The discussion connects the debate to rising living costs and middle class households feeling nearer to social vulnerability. Funding is messy too. Some schemes use government money. Others come from private foundations or technology entrepreneurs willing to bankroll experiments. The tech thread is direct. Sam Altman's proposed 2016 study leads into a five-year experiment begun in 2019 with low-income participants in Illinois and Texas. Even the payments differ sharply: $50 a month for some, $1,000 for others. Jack Dorsey, Mark Zuckerberg, and Elon Musk also appear as technology figures who have publicly backed related income ideas. The episode keeps its footing cautious. One guest sees freedom and a less paternalistic state in the idea. A more cynical reading hears anxiety about jobs lost to automation.

As heard by us

A clear primer on why basic income keeps resurfacing in welfare debates, tech circles, and arguments over automation.

Basic income is treated as a live policy fight, not a slogan. The episode starts with Ireland's decision to keep cash payments for 2,000 artists, then widens into the question of why governments, researchers, and tech figures keep circling back to no-strings income support.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the case for basic income, plus the sceptic's version of it.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on
Apple PodcastsSpotify
Play clips from this episodeMore from The Inquiry