The ATP Tennis Radio Podcast · ATP Media

PODCAST SPECIAL - GOAT Debate Part 1

·34 min·3 clips

Does Novak Djokovic's 24 majors make him the GOAT, or is greatness more than just silverware?

This episode debates how to define the greatest tennis player of all time, considering factors beyond major titles. Host Seb Lozier is joined by tennis journalist and biographer Chris Bowers and former WTA player Jill Craybas. The discussion examines Novak Djokovic equaling Margaret Court's 24 singles majors and his leading head-to-head records against Rafael Nadal and Roger Federer. Chris Bowers notes Djokovic's 24 Grand Slam titles, Nadal's 22, and Federer's 20, while questioning if doubles titles, like Martina Navratilova's 41, should count. Jill Craybas highlights Serena Williams's 23 singles and 14 doubles majors, plus her cultural transcendence. Commentator Brad Stine and analyst Craig O'Shaughnessy are cited arguing Djokovic's current statistical supremacy. Ivan Ljubičić states Djokovic is the greatest based on his winning record and titles. A key insight is the challenge of comparing eras, especially pre-1968 when professionals were barred from majors. Paul Haarhuis praises Nadal's consistency, citing 15 consecutive years in the top ten and 14 French Open titles. Craybas recalls Nadal studying Federer's practice to improve on grass. Bowers details Federer's peak dominance, winning 11 of 16 majors from 2004-2007. The panel discusses how all three men reinvented their games, like Nadal adjusting his baseline position after 2011 losses to Djokovic. The conversation covers Djokovic's 43-match winning streak in 2011 and Federer's 23 consecutive Grand Slam semifinals. Wheelchair tennis champions like Esther Vergeer, with a 470-match streak, are noted for extraordinary but sometimes overlooked achievements. Bowers suggests Djokovic and Serena Williams were likely motivated by chasing records, while Nadal was driven purely by daily improvement. Craybas believes all modern greats appreciate historical predecessors and see themselves among the best, not necessarily as the single greatest. The tone is analytical and conversational, balancing statistical deep dives with personal anecdotes from players and insiders. It adopts an educational style, exploring historical context and different metrics for greatness. Tennis fans fascinated by statistics, historical comparisons, and the "Big Three" rivalry will find this episode compelling. Listeners seeking a definitive answer or a debate focused solely on style and celebrity might prefer to wait for the second part.

As heard by us

A measured tennis debate that treats greatness as a question, not a slogan.

The GOAT debate is handled as a serious tennis argument about how greatness should be measured: results, substance, style, and celebrity. Seb Lozier keeps the conversation clear, while Chris Bowers and Jill Krabus give it shape as it moves through Djokovic's record, Nadal's clay…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a measured GOAT debate that weighs trophies against context.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The ATP Tennis Radio Podcast