A Bob Dylan Beginner's Guide, with Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell

September 19, 2025·1 hr 54 min·5 clips

Matt recalls buying Bob Dylan's Greatest Hits and hearing 'Like a Rolling Stone' for the first time on a school bus.

This episode of Strong Songs features host Kirk Hamilton in conversation with Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell, co-hosts of the politics podcast Know Your Enemy, who are also lifelong Bob Dylan experts. The discussion serves as a beginner's guide to Dylan's vast and daunting career, prompted by Kirk's own admitted intimidation. The conversation critiques the 2024 Bob Dylan biopic "A Complete Unknown," starring Timothée Chalamet, which all three hosts found unilluminating and structurally flawed. They analyze Dylan's notorious live performances, where he often radically rearranges his songs, leading some audiences to feel he shows contempt while fans see it as a lack of reverence for his own material. Matt recounts discovering Dylan through a "Greatest Hits" CD in high school and later becoming obsessed with the bootleg trading scene, using websites like Expecting Rain. Sam describes his connection to Dylan as almost primal, recalling teenage rebellion fueled by albums like "Highway 61 Revisited." Kirk shares his early, disjointed exposures to Dylan through the Forrest Gump soundtrack and Peter, Paul and Mary's cover of "Blowing in the Wind." A key insight is that Dylan functions as a gateway into a wider universe of American music, from bluegrass to jazz, a role reflected in his book "The Philosophy of Modern Song" and his "Theme Time Radio Hour." The hosts reference a poignant anecdote from Dylan's memoir "Chronicles," where Thelonious Monk tells him, "We all play folk music," linking Dylan's work to a jazz tradition of improvisation and moment-specific performance. They contrast Dylan's unpredictable, ever-changing setlists with the static, choreographed shows of modern pop stars like Taylor Swift. The episode has a warm, conversational tone between three friends who share a deep, analytical appreciation for music. It is educational in structure, breaking down Dylan's artistic philosophy and offering listeners a curated entry point into his discography. This episode is perfect for anyone curious about Bob Dylan but unsure where to start, or for fans of deep-dive music analysis. Listeners seeking a straightforward biography or those with no interest in Dylan's music might choose to skip it.

As heard by us

A steady entry point to Dylan's sprawl, with enough context to make the scale feel manageable.

Kirk treats Bob Dylan's catalog as something too large to pretend to master, and that restraint gives the episode its shape. Rather than arriving with a polished thesis, he starts from his own distance from Dylan and brings in Matt Sitman and Sam Adler-Bell to help open the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a way into Dylan's sprawl with two experts holding the map and the landmarks?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Strong Songs