Holy Wednesday At The Dog Cathedral

April 1, 2026·1 hr 18 min·6 clips

Spencer Hall claims he's the most Catholic host because he abandoned the faith for militant atheism after a childhood flirtation.

Jason starts with a trapdoor question. After saying in a DM that he is the least Catholic host, he asks who is most Catholic, and the table immediately treats not going to church as evidence. Spencer gets nominated because he does not practice. Ryan makes his own case with childhood practice, teenage abandonment, adult flirtation, and a later turn toward militant atheism, which someone quickly downgrades to agnosticism. That becomes its own doctrine. The running joke is that Catholic identity survives almost any escape attempt: distance, doubt, nonattendance, even the wish to stand much farther away. Converts then wander into range. The panel compares normal people and weird people on both sides, while leaning on insiders who say the weird is easier to spot among people who join. Writing the journey down sounds suspicious. If the conversion is really Catholic, the move should be buried, not stretched into a book length victory lap. The Bible bit keeps escalating. Jason says the Catholic Bible is huge, so everyone treats the extra material as stuff nobody reads. Administration becomes the joke. Catholicism is framed less as a direct user manual and more as a massive interpretive office that tells people what matters. It is the original fake ChatGPT. The bit keeps moving through scripture remixing, ordered readings, and the idea that confusion can be solved by reading less, but with confidence. Then style beats doctrine. European churches make Catholicism look flashy, theatrical, and oddly stylish, which leaves JD Vance as the foil. The test is not theology. It is whether someone would wear a tricked out Virgin Mary necklace, survive the festival chaos, or fit in with the swaggy Catholics in Louisiana and Central America.

As heard by us

Catholic identity becomes a running joke, and the argument keeps sharpening it.

The segment treats Catholic identity as something argued over in real time, with practice, distance, and self-description all pulled into the same joke.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a Catholic debate to turn into a fast, ridiculous bit about who is the most Catholic.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Shutdown Fullcast