Serial Killer Podcast Documentary · Peter Jesse

True Crime Documentary - Sade Robinson and The Secret Beach

March 15, 2026·41 min·1 clip

There was just no way for that to get there by accident—that's when I knew I had a homicide.

This episode investigates the 2024 disappearance and murder of 19-year-old college student Sade Robinson in Milwaukee. The narrative is driven by lead detective Joe Donner of the Milwaukee County Sheriff's Office and Milwaukee Police Detective Nora Donegan. A severed leg was discovered by a walker at a secluded Lake Michigan shoreline area called Warnemont Park on April 2nd. Detective Donner connected this to a missing person report filed for Sade Robinson, who vanished after a first date with a man named Maxwell Anderson. Sade's burned car was found three miles from her apartment, with her purse hidden under the seat and her clothing, turned inside out, discovered in the trunk. Investigators determined the driver's seat was positioned for someone at least six feet tall, unlike 5'3" Sade. Data from Sade's Life360 app showed her phone died at Warnemont Park at 4:35 a.m. after her car traveled erratically for hours. Security footage from a nearby building captured a shadowy figure dragging an item toward the lake and later walking away with a large backpack. Maxwell Anderson, a 33-year-old bartender Sade met days prior, had a criminal history including battery and disorderly conduct. His ex-girlfriend, Chloe Wright, told police he had a "secret beach," which she directed them to—it was Warnemont Park. Despite searching Anderson's home and finding 51 knives, police lacked a murder weapon or bloody crime scene. Anderson was arrested and charged with homicide, mutilation, and arson after DNA confirmed the remains were Sade's. At trial, crucial evidence included bus footage of Anderson carrying a backpack after Sade's car was set ablaze and a jacket with Sade's DNA found in a neighbor's trash. The most disturbing evidence was deleted photos from Anderson's phone showing Sade facedown in his home with a man's hand on her. The defense highlighted the lack of a known murder weapon or motive and the unrecovered cause of death. The jury found Maxwell Anderson guilty of all charges after less than an hour of deliberation. At sentencing, he maintained his innocence, while Sade's family pleaded for the return of her still-missing head. The tone is a serious, investigative documentary blending detective interviews, trial testimony, and emotional family accounts. The style is narrative-driven, building suspense through chronological discovery and forensic detail. True crime enthusiasts interested in forensic investigation and legal procedure will be gripped by this detailed case study. Listeners sensitive to descriptions of violence against women or unresolved emotional endings might find this episode particularly distressing.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Serial Killer Podcast Documentary