Star Wars The Acolyte Episode 3 Dropped And Oh Man Has It Stirred Up The Internet!!!

·1 hr 32 min·5 clips

Darth Butcher admits he really liked The Acolyte episode 3, despite expecting to hate it.

The episode opens with host Darth Butcher and co-hosts Scott Solo and Grand Admiral Franz welcoming listeners and thanking their Patreon supporters. They immediately address the internet frenzy surrounding The Acolyte episode 3. Darth Butcher confesses he actually liked the episode, appreciating its dialogue-driven approach to Star Wars lore, though he acknowledges it wasn't perfect. The hosts discuss the episode's flashback to 16 years prior, showing the Jedi's arrival to take the twins Osha and Mae. They analyze the coven of witches, their creation of the twins through the force, and the Jedi's intervention. A major theory emerges: the witches' unnatural creation of life might be the lost knowledge that Darth Plagueis and Palpatine later sought to replicate, potentially making Anakin Skywalker the force's reaction to this dark side act. The hosts debate whether this tarnishes Anakin's chosen one story, concluding it might actually enhance it. They critique specific elements like the 'cringy' witch chant in English, questionable acting from the twin actors, and the logic of a stone castle catching fire. Throughout, they examine the Jedi's increasingly corrupt and bureaucratic portrayal, comparing them to child-snatching authorities. Listener comments are integrated, including praise for the show's non-toxic analysis and concerns about the storyline. The discussion connects the twins' potential dyad to the sequel trilogy's concept and speculates on future episodes revealing more perspectives on the Jedi's actions. The episode ends with a defense of creators' intentions and a hope that the full story will justify the narrative choices.

As heard by us

A loose Star Wars debate finds real tension in who gets to decide a child's path to the Jedi.

Starlight Digest lands on a pointed Star Wars question: how children end up with the Jedi, and whether that process looks different when viewed from the witches' side.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Jedi child-recruitment questions, witch-side tension, and a room happy to let the debate get messy.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Sarlacc Digest: A Star Wars Podcast