Sacrilegious Discourse - Bible Study for Atheists · Husband & Wife

2 Maccabees Chapters 11 - 15 Q&A: Bible Study by Atheists

April 8, 2026·45 min·4 clips

Why do you need prophets if you can justify any behavior like the God of the Bible?

2 Macadoodles is cleanup duty. The pair has finished chapters 11 through 15, so the chapter grind pauses for a Q&A about confusion, names, and ancient paperwork. They want answers, or at least fewer reasons to yell at the page. The cold open starts with the bigger annoyance: why the God of the Bible needs prophets to explain who he is and what he wants. That frustration stays in the room. Their Bible-study mode is still skeptical, quick, and unwilling to treat murder as noble just because the book says so. Then the calendar problem shows up. One host tries to work out when the letters in chapter 11 were written and lands on roughly 163 to 161 BCE. The other host keeps checking the math. Fair enough, since Maccabees has already made timelines, naming systems, and simple-looking notation feel like a trap. BCE gets separated from SE. That matters because SE points to a different dating system tied to years after the Babylonian exile, not just another way to count around Jesus. The correction stays patient without getting fussy. They keep the question narrow and avoid falling into the authorship rabbit hole, even though it is right there. Authorship can wait. The broader time period, compilation questions, and more Maccadoodles context are saved for the next episode instead of being jammed into this one. Somehow, restraint wins. The fun is in the back-and-forth: every okay sounds like someone trying to keep the map from sliding off the table. They are not pretending any of this is graceful. They are trying to make ancient letters, shifting calendars, and tangled religious history readable without hiding how absurd the process feels. The ending snaps back to podcast chores, with Patreon support, Apple reviews, likes, subscriptions, and Twitter piled into one deliberately overstuffed list. It lands small and married: a thank-you, a joke about asking for too much, and a clean exit. Less lecture, more couple sorting ancient chaos at the kitchen table.

As heard by us

A clear wrap-up of 2 Maccabees that sorts out the dating in chapters 11-15.

This review closes out 2 Maccabees by sorting the chronology in chapters 11-15, especially the letters dated to 163-161 BCE and the mix-up between BCE and SE dating.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want 2 Maccabees' dating puzzle untangled without losing the jokes.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Sacrilegious Discourse - Bible Study for Atheists