RotoViz Fantasy Football Show · Blue Wire

3 Decisions I Regret from Fantasy Draft Season

October 28, 2025·42 min·2 clips

Jerry Judy's 22 catches on 52 targets show volume without efficient production.

1. RotoViz Fantasy Football Show focuses on draft mistakes from August and how they might affect this season. 2. Colm Kelly hosts the show, says he pre-recorded it before traveling, and frames the discussion around FFPC roster percentages and ADP. 3. The episode asks which draft decisions were real mistakes and which picks were only bad in hindsight. 4. Kelly starts with RJ Harvey, citing his 37 carries and 17 receptions on 20 targets through the season. 5. He notes that Harvey went as running back 20 in the fifth round in best ball drafts. 6. Kelly places Harvey beside Tony Pollard, James Conner, Chuba Hubbard, and TreVeyon Henderson at similar draft prices. 7. He argues that Emeka Egbuka, George Pickens, and Davante Smith were better pivots from that draft range. 8. Kelly also says Harvey’s value has been hurt by a backfield that has not matched the rookie running back thesis. 9. Jerry Judy is the next major regret, and Kelly says he is on 61% of Kelly’s FFPC teams across formats. 10. Judy’s season line is 22 receptions on 52 targets, with Kelly highlighting an early 5-for-66 game and later low-output weeks. 11. Kelly says the combination of quarterback play, drops, and inconsistent production has made Judy hard to trust. 12. Tyler Warren becomes the clearest alternative, with Kelly saying Warren is averaging 14.5 points per game on 45 targets, 33 catches, and three touchdowns. 13. Kelly also mentions Rome Odunze and says he would rather have Warren than Judy from the same area of the draft. 14. The running back regret section expands to Javonte Williams, Jayden Blue, and Basial Tootin in the 10th round range. 15. Kelly says Williams is averaging 18.7 points per game with 111 carries, nearly 600 yards, six rushing touchdowns, 23 receptions, and one receiving touchdown. 16. He says Blue may need an injury or a major role change to matter, while Williams currently leads the Dallas backfield. 17. The tone is reflective and process-driven, with Kelly repeatedly comparing ADP decisions to current roster outcomes. 18. The format is solo, conversational, and self-auditing, with side references to World Mental Health Day and BetterHelp sponsorship. 19. Listeners who track FFPC drafts, rookie ADP, and roster construction will get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners who want game-by-game analysis or team news may want to skip it.

As heard by us

A tight draft postmortem that weighs August ADP against real pivot points and separates regret from what was never easy to fix.

Colm Kelly looks back at the August draft with a clear eye for the spots that still linger. He ties the regret to the ADP he was working with at the time, which keeps the piece grounded in the market rather than in easy hindsight.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to review August draft mistakes against the ADP and pivot points that were actually available.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from RotoViz Fantasy Football Show