11.23-The Trial of the Earthlings

April 21, 2025·34 min·3 clips

Bruno October's last words before execution: 'I know where the bombs are hidden.'

1. Revolutions, episode 11.23, covers the 'Trial of the Earthlings' — a tribunal process on Mars in February–April 2251 that adjudicated roughly one thousand Earthling detainees following the Martian independence struggle. 2. The episode is narrated by Mike Duncan in his solo analytical format; no guests appear, and Duncan draws on in-universe secondary sources such as biographies of Coyote O'Hara, Billy Shrimps, and Aveline Wren. 3. The episode's central question is whether a revolutionary government can run a fact-based legal process when public pressure is actively threatening riots if the 'wrong' verdict is returned. 4. Minister Marcus Leopold organized a three-tier tribunal system — initial three-judge panels, an intermediate appellate level, and a High Tribunal — and staffed it with veteran advocates from Omnicorps' old legal division. 5. For Earthlings, the best possible outcome was acquittal; guilty verdicts carried deportation; but for 23 identified ringleaders, the crimes were deemed too severe for deportation and death sentences were imposed. 6. Martians, by contrast, could not be deported under any circumstances — the host notes this was 'almost irrationally seared into the Martian psyche' — and faced fines, confinement, or community service instead. 7. Kenji Grew posted daily polemics whipping up anger against the Earthling prisoners, and in late February 2251 coined the phrase 'Earth or Death' — deportation or execution, with no third option for Earthlings on Mars. 8. As the tribunals opened, the host reports a measurable jump in incidents of harassment, assault, vandalism, and property damage against Earthlings not accused of any crime. 9. The hero of Phobos, Booth Gonzales, enlisted in the newly formed Martian Navy alongside three civilian captains — Coyote O'Hara, Billy Shrimps, and Aveline Wren — who the host flags as future major figures. 10. Admirals Cartwright and Way determined that the Martian Navy's 287 security gunships and 515 civilian vessels should sail back to Earth to reinforce Three Corps, rather than sit in a defensive posture around Mars. 11. The Bruno October case was the most contentious: the man handed over by his own men, who claimed he was the insurrection's ringleader, but all supporting testimony was circular hearsay with no corroborating evidence. 12. October complicated his tribunal by simultaneously denying all charges and making obviously false boasts — claiming to have invented corridor hockey and to be a quadruple agent for Saturn itself. 13. The High Tribunal ultimately convicted October despite the evidentiary weakness of the case, explicitly aware that acquittal would likely trigger the riots Kenji Grew had promised. 14. The host editorializes that the verdict was 'right' in outcome but 'not great from a legal point of view,' and that it set a dangerous precedent for future proceedings. 15. The 23 convicted ringleaders were executed on April 15, 2251 by oxygen deprivation in groups of five, with the death sentence read aloud before each group. 16. Bruno October's last words — 'Pity you're killing me. I know where the bombs are hidden' — went unresolved; the host notes José Calderón witnessed the statement and was visibly disturbed. 17. The episode alternates between the tribunal storyline and the Martian Navy's preparation to depart for Earth, with the two threads converging when the Navy was asked to wait for deportees to be processed before sailing. 18. The tone is measured and analytical, with Duncan occasionally breaking frame to evaluate the quality of revolutionary institutions — approving of the tribunal's structure while condemning its susceptibility to mob pressure. 19. Listeners following the full Martian Revolution arc and interested in revolutionary justice, mob politics, and the tension between rule of law and popular anger will find this episode essential. 20. Those new to the series, or those expecting combat action rather than legal and political drama, will find this episode slow and densely plotted.

As heard by us

The Martian Navy's voyage to Earth becomes a tense study of politics, personnel, and unfinished danger.

The Martian Navy's departure for Earth is less a clean military transfer than a sorting of usefulness, loyalty, and fear. Booth Gonzales is pulled off his own ship and placed beside Cartwright, Way, and the Admiralty staff, not because he has suddenly become a grand strategist,…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Play this if you want the setup before the big break goes wrong.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Revolutions