Paper Ghosts · iHeartPodcasts

Piss Hill

November 5, 2025·53 min·4 clips

A witness heard gunshots disguised by thunder on Piss Hill the night two teenagers vanished.

The children did not come home. From that first absence, the narration turns to Vincent Jr., remembered as caring, sweet, protective, and unusually responsible. He carried a lot early. He helped his father with the business, earned straight A's, practiced martial arts, raised cattle, and helped raise his sisters. The point is not to make him sound perfect. It is to make him real: a son and brother whose everyday goodness makes the loss hurt more. His baby sister was close to him. Someone remembers the small house he built for her, with electric and plumbing, a birthday clubhouse that feels less like a kid's project than a quiet act of devotion. He took her everywhere. That detail lands hard because protection keeps coming back in the witness account. Asked whether Vincent had trouble with anyone at school or anywhere else, the answer is simple: nobody had a problem with him. His plans were practical and tied to home. He wanted to help expand his father's business and keep his family taken care of, a future built around duty, not escape. Then the episode pulls wider. The host moves from memory into the limits of the investigation, saying a 1983 crime scene was not handled the way it would be handled today. Time made the scene harder to read. Older procedure left room for doubt, and the way the scene was handled becomes another reason the case refuses a clean answer. The closing recollection is colder. Someone says they were told they could not question, with the reason tied to the mayor or something involving the mayor. That is not closure. It is a troubling memory, with grief, authority, and missing answers gathered around the same absence.

As heard by us

A grave, witness-led true crime episode about grief, procedure, and the limits of what the case could recover.

Paper Ghosts focuses on the night the kids did not come home and builds its case around memory, silence, and what people remember after the fact. Vincent Jr.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want family memory colliding with official silence in a cold case.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Paper Ghosts