Our True Crime Podcast · Our True Crime Podcast

Unsolved: Bill & Peggy Stephenson with Melissa From Just the Tip-Sters

·1 hr 3 min·3 clips

This case starts with ordinary life. The hosts place Bill and Peggy inside a specific church world, one that feels steady and local rather than dramatic, with Peggy at the organ and Bill serving as deacon while also running a truckers ministry that accepted donations but did not charge a fee. That matters. The conversation keeps circling the gap between public image and private reality, because a churchgoing couple can look simple on the surface and still leave behind a mess that does not line up neatly. The tone stays skeptical. Instead of using the religious setting as a shortcut to an answer, the episode uses it to show the texture of the couple's day-to-day life and the kind of respect they seem to have had in their community. There is also a fair bit of banter. The back-and-forth moves into jokes about Baptist varieties and other small asides, but it keeps coming back to the case, which gives the whole thing a lived-in, table-side feel. That rhythm helps. You get the sense that the hosts are trying to make sense of a long-running investigation rather than hand over a neat, closed narrative. The detective angle is the emotional core. A longtime investigator, someone the host clearly trusts, is described as the kind of person who would not retire until the case was solved, and then retired in August 2025 after decades on the job. That stings. The show turns that detail into a reminder that some cases outlast talent, patience, and stubbornness, and that even the best investigator can end up leaving the file unfinished. There is real admiration here. The detective comes across as relentless and seasoned, the sort who could be pulled off other work and called back when needed. The episode does not rush. It lets the listener sit with the fact that the case still has edges that will not smooth out, and that uncertainty is part of its force. The result feels grounded. It plays like a conversation about a family, a church, a town, and a case that has stayed open long enough to shape the people trying to solve it.

As heard by us

A grounded cold case story that keeps the focus on ordinary people.

The episode keeps Bill and Peggy at the center as ordinary church people first, which gives the case its pull. Peggy is at the organ, Bill is the deacon, and his free truckers ministry adds a small detail that makes their world feel lived in.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a stubborn cold case told with Baptist-church detail and skeptical, talk-at-the-table banter that keeps pressing.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Our True Crime Podcast