Elaine had been bound and gagged with duct tape and went into labor during the assault. Her newborn baby, a girl named Casey, had been delivered and immediately killed.
As heard by us
A grim unsolved murder case, told with skepticism and enough doubt to keep every claim under pressure.
The episode frames the family murders as a grim case of violence, doubt, and dead ends. It lingers on the parts that matter: Keith's caution around strangers, Sell's shaky confession, and the way the search for a suspect kept slipping away.
Why you'd press play
Want a hard, skeptical look at a family killing with no clean answer at the end?
Listen to the show on