163* The Drama of Celebrity with Sharon Marcus (JP)

January 29, 2026·32 min·2 clips

Sharon Marcus calls the distinction between fame and celebrity 'bullshit,' revealing it as a tool for assigning social status.

The starting point is celebrity itself. Instead of treating fame as background noise, the conversation follows Sharon Marcus through the theories that try to explain why stars matter. The political angle comes early. Reagan and Trump help separate celebrity politics tied to governing experience from celebrity politics without it. The host keeps asking for context, which gives Marcus room to connect those examples to a bigger question: are publics passive, active, numbed out, or trying to imagine themselves into being? Punk shifts the scale. Subculture complicates the clean split between fan and rock star, especially when style becomes part of the scene. The academic thread matters too. The Birmingham school, Stuart Hall, Hebdige, and Adorno come in as part of a longer argument about mass culture and community. No single theory gets to take the whole prize. Marcus's strongest point is that industry power, fan choice, and self-fashioning can all be true without explaining everything. That tension gives the episode its shape. Stars can be made by institutions, but they still need audiences to decide whether the public image feels believable. Marcus also keeps the folk theory alive. The idea that stars make themselves may not carry much academic prestige, but it still affects why people care. Belief becomes part of how celebrity works. A fan is not just handed meaning from above; the fan helps decide whether the star's meaning lands. The exchange stays theoretical, but it has a nice slow build, moving from sofa passivity to punk participation, from celebrity presidents to everyday ideas about why stars seem self-made.

As heard by us

Celebrity is treated as culture, industry, and fan making.

Marcus treats celebrity as a social fact, and the episode moves through Reagan and Trump, punk, subculture, the Birmingham school, Adorno, and the idea that stars make themselves. The point is not to pick a winner.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want celebrity explained without the usual hand-waving.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from New Books in Music