Malevolent · Harlan Guthrie

THRESHOLD | Part 1 "Dead Man's Mouthpiece"

April 1, 2026·52 min·4 clips

Sam admits he tried animals first and needs a heart before Arthur fires.

1. Malevolent's 'Threshold | Part 1 "Dead Man's Mouthpiece"' follows Arthur Lester and John through a rainy Arnett barn case in Arkham. 2. Arthur Lester narrates as the private investigator, John speaks from inside Arthur's body, and Michael Callahan matters as the Arkham officer who later sees the scene. 3. The episode asks whether the barn contains a squatter, a ritual, or a murder tied to a page torn from an old book. 4. Arnett hires Arthur after three nights of a figure in the fields, missing livestock, and signs of someone living in the barn. 5. Arthur and John trade jokes about sleep, time out, and who gets to rest while the other watches the barn. 6. Their conversation keeps drifting to Faroe, because Arthur wants more time before explaining John to her and fears upsetting the life she already knows. 7. The barn approach uses rain, lightning, hay bales, crates, and a loft that functions like a maze. 8. Arthur and John find Sam, a knife, a bloodied sigil, and a torn page from a book on the loft floor. 9. Sam says he tried animals first and now needs a heart because he has to stop someone who does 'terrible things.' 10. A young man is still alive on the floor when Sam moves to finish the ritual, and Arthur fires to stop him. 11. The episode uses Sam's confession to turn a suspected squatter story into a direct occult threat without naming the larger force behind it. 12. Callahan arrives after the shot, returns Arthur's gun, and immediately understands enough to treat the scene as a self-defense case. 13. Arthur and John then try to reconstruct what the sigil, the page, and the blood at the floor were meant to do. 14. The paper appears to match the floor sigil and includes symbols Arthur recognizes from earlier supernatural cases. 15. John and Arthur also compare their current arrangement to the time Lilith controlled Arthur's whole body. 16. They conclude that projecting, controlling the left side, and touching the dead have become the tools that keep them effective. 17. The episode's style leans on fast, overlapping dialogue and precise spatial narration, especially when the pair climbs into the loft. 18. Its energy shifts from resentment and gallows humor to forensic dread, then to a quieter dinner scene with Faroe. 19. Listeners who like serialized occult detective horror with family stakes will get the most from it. 20. Skip if you want standalone stories with no continuity.

As heard by us

A rescue scene tightens into ritual, police light, and one very bad breathless minute.

The episode keeps the room under real pressure: Arthur, Sam, a knife, a gun, and a young man on the floor all crowd into the same instant before anyone can land on a clean way out.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a tense listen where a rescue turns into a police-in-the-maze scramble.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Malevolent