This episode of the horror fiction podcast Malevolent follows protagonists Arthur Lester and the entity John Doe as they return to Arthur's office after a long absence. The hosts are the characters themselves, voiced by creator Harlan Guthrie, navigating a supernatural mystery. Their return marks a potential new beginning for their investigative partnership.
Arthur and John find Arthur's office restored, with a fixed window and his piano still present. They discover a music box left as a gift from Luna, Tom, and the patrons of the Waylay for a character named Blackstone. A letter from Arthur's father-in-law, Daniel, is also waiting, expressing a changed perspective. Daniel references a kindly priest named Oscar through whom he has come to understand Arthur better. Arthur recalls first meeting Daniel and recommending a poem, which Daniel now thanks him for. At John's request, Arthur recites the poem "If—" by Rudyard Kipling from memory. Following this moment, Arthur expresses a desire for a bath and a meal. Their landlord, Hannah Burner, then enters, frustrated at having to manage the office in their absence. Hannah complains about fetching mail and watering plants, suggesting they hire a secretary.
The letter from Daniel reveals his personal reflection and admission that he lost his way, but is now carving a new path. Daniel's note signifies a hard-won reconciliation and understanding between him and Arthur. The gift of the music box suggests that some residents of the supernatural location the Waylay survived its earlier turmoil. Arthur's recitation of the classic poem about perseverance and integrity resonates deeply with their recent traumatic experiences. The mundane frustration of their landlord sharply contrasts with the epic supernatural trials they have just endured.
The tone is intimate and atmospheric, blending quiet character moments with eerie, unresolved tension. The style is narrative-driven and conversational between the two central characters. Listeners who enjoy character-driven horror with emotional depth and literary references will appreciate this episode. Those seeking action-packed plot advancement or horror set pieces might find this reflective installment too slow.
