Horror Movie Talk · Horror Movie Talk: Horror Movie Review

Black Phone 2 Review

October 22, 2025·1 hr 23 min·6 clips

Max, Bryce, and Sydney review Black Phone 2, scoring it 1-10 before diving into spoilers.

The review starts orderly. Max Allen brings in Bryce Hansen and Sydney Lee, the promo chatter clears out, and Black Phone 2 moves to the center. Then the title starts to wobble. The panel notices that the black phone itself no longer feels like the main engine, even though the first movie made it the clean supernatural device. Gwen starts to take over. Instead of Finn stuck in one room with one creepy object, the sequel sends visions, calls, and dead voices through a wider setup. That gives the movie more to play with, but it also muddies the rules. One person argues the logic still works: the grabber is dead, so the same line can help and hurt. The rest of the table keeps testing that idea. If any phone can do the job, then the color sounds more like branding than a rule. Naturally, that becomes the joke. Finn gets framed as an accidental phone conduit, taking calls whether the thing is connected or not. Gwen makes the read even slipperier. She hears the phone sometimes, maybe when the mother is calling, but the excerpt never fully pins that down. The panel sounds amused and irritated in equal measure. They are not allergic to supernatural mess; they just want the sequel to know what kind of mess it is using. The first movie gives them a sharp comparison point: Finn, a room, a chorus of dead kids, and one memorable phone with a clear job. Here the mythology spreads outward. That can make the story feel bigger, but it also leaves the title object oddly optional. The best stretch is the argument itself. Nobody treats the movie too delicately, so the review can move from horror logic to a dumb, stubborn bit about phone color without losing the thread. The ads crowd the edges, but the main voice still lands: quick, skeptical, and happy to laugh while trying to figure out the rules.

As heard by us

A sequel review that keeps arguing with its own rules.

Black Phone 2 Review treats the sequel as both a scare machine and a logic test. It keeps circling what the black phone means now that the Grabber is gone, why Gwen carries more of the story than Finn, and whether the movie can keep its own supernatural rules in one piece.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want a Black Phone 2 review that keeps circling the phone, Gwen, Finn, and the Grabber.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Horror Movie Talk