EconTalk · Russ Roberts

The Wonder of the Emergent Mind (with Gaurav Suri)

November 17, 2025·1 hr 40 min·5 clips

How do ants always find the shortest path without a leader or map?

The conversation starts with Suri's book sitting between machinery and meaning. Roberts frames it as a nuts and bolts account of neural networks and large language models, and also as a book about human experience. The liveliest stretch is free will. Suri does not do the easy neuroscientific move of calling it unreal and leaving it there. Goals matter. He describes them as subnetworks of activation that help steer action, even inside a deterministic system. Roberts slows that down, which is where the episode works best. He restates the determinism claim back to Suri and asks to be corrected if he has it wrong. No rush to a slogan. Suri's answer treats human beings as part of nature, not exceptions to it. Trees, stars, animals, water flowing downstream: the comparison could sound bleak, but the mood is not bleak. For Suri, seeing people as context shaped processes can make blame less automatic and life feel more like unfolding than command. The ending gets wider without losing the thread. Thought comes across as rare, fragile, and capable of kindness and construction on a planet moving through deep space. Big stuff, yes, but the episode keeps coming back to usable words: goals, processes, context, bodies, experience, and what free will can still mean after determinism is taken seriously.

As heard by us

The free-will argument Suri makes here -- that goal pursuit is real even inside a deterministic system -- is worth the whole hour.

Gaurav Suri and Russ Roberts spend most of this episode on "The Emergent Mind," the book Suri wrote with Jay McClelland, which holds that human and machine intelligence run on the same networked, deterministic processes. The free-will section is the best part.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Gaurav Suri argues you are a deterministic process -- and somehow that is quietly good news.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from EconTalk