Dealin' the Cards: A St. Louis Cardinals Podcast

E281: The Cardinals Sign Dustin May - Initial Reactions

·57 min·5 clips

The Cardinals just signed Dustin May in an emergency move—what does this mean for their 2026 rotation?

This emergency podcast episode focuses on the St. Louis Cardinals signing pitcher Dustin May to a one-year deal for the 2026 season. Hosts Josh and Andrew react to this unexpected front office move by Heimblum. The hosts humorously note the inconvenient timing of the news, with Josh revealing he is recording while recovering from a back injury sustained from a fall on ice. The episode centers on the one-year agreement with former Los Angeles Dodgers player Dustin May to replenish the Cardinals' rotation. Josh states that May has consistently been his preferred target for an upside free agent starter this offseason. The hosts mention they have not yet seen the exact financial terms of the contract. They joke that May, coming from Los Angeles, will need to get used to Midwest snow, despite baseball being a summer sport. The signing is framed as the Cardinals fishing in a specific market for pitchers. A key insight is the characterization of this as a pure upside move for the future, with no immediate impact for the upcoming season. The hosts express personal excitement, with Josh calling May "my guy" among available options. The discussion is prompted by the surprise of the news breaking while Josh was sleeping and trying to recover from his injury. The timing is also noted as inconvenient ahead of their scheduled charity stream on Tuesday. The tone is informal and reactionary, fitting an emergency recording. The style is conversational and lighthearted, featuring personal anecdotes and jokes alongside the baseball analysis. This episode is ideal for St. Louis Cardinals fans seeking immediate fan reactions to a new player acquisition. Listeners looking for in-depth statistical analysis or official contract details might find it less substantive.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Dealin' the Cards: A St. Louis Cardinals Podcast