Crimelines · Mode Podcast

Blood Trail in Hyannis

May 9, 2025·22 min·1 clip

A sweet potato used as a silencer links Todd Lampley's murder to an HBO series, baffling investigators.

Hyannis is introduced gently. The village on Cape Cod comes in through water, beaches, boutiques, seafood, and memories of John F. Kennedy summers. Then the view narrows fast. On February 27, 2011, 31-year-old Todd Lampley is killed by a shot through the window of his room. The scene does not settle into an easy answer. The excerpt says shocking evidence tied fictional stories to the murder, which gives the search for truth a strange, almost sideways feeling. Then years pass with no answer. The case stays unresolved until Hampton appears before a judge in Barnstable District Court on February 27, 2023. That date lands hard because it is exactly 12 years after the fatal shooting. The courtroom is tense, and Hampton pleads not guilty. The prosecution gives little away. Assistant District Attorney Russell Enis does not explain the delay and says only that the evidence has been assessed. The defense pushes back. Court-appointed attorney Edward Fogarty promises a vigorous defense and says he is confident in Hampton's innocence. A next court date is set for April 5, 2023. Still, the narration does not treat the naming of a suspect as the finish line. The investigation is described as unfinished. The excerpt also does not give a clear motive for Todd Lampley's killing. Then the transcript wanders. A later passage shifts into the unsolved killing of Army Private Amanda Gonzalez in Hanau, Germany, and the closing material seems to belong to another case or another segment. The Hyannis case remains the center: a delayed prosecution, a defendant saying he is innocent, and evidence that keeps the official story from feeling settled.

As heard by us

A Hyannis killing slowly opens into a sober case with an unsettling evidentiary trail.

The episode follows a Hyannis killing that started with a man shot through the window of his room and did not get an answer for 12 years. It moves with calm, documentarian control from the Cape Cod setting to a 2023 courtroom appearance, and it keeps the strange detail at the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a Cape Cod murder case that took 12 years to crack.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Crimelines