Conversations with Peter Boghossian · Peter Boghossian

HEATED DEBATE On Islam, Immigration, and Israel: Shabbos Kestenbaum vs Cameraman

February 24, 2026·2 hr 5 min·5 clips

Shabbos Kestenbaum confronts a cameraman who says he doesn't believe Jewish students were physically assaulted at Harvard.

The dispute starts small. A claim about Jewish American students being physically assaulted at Harvard turns into a sharper fight over belief, verification, and who gets to call something false. The phone almost becomes another participant. One speaker keeps reaching for a fact-check, while the other argues that someone who was there should be heard before being waved off. That irritation sets the tone. The question is not only whether Harvard failed to protect students, but why testimony becomes suspect when it comes from the person making the claim. Then the subject widens. A heated claim about religious groups and crime drags the conversation into evidence, examples, and the line between criticism and racism. Nobody sounds fully satisfied, which may be the most honest part of it. The argument keeps coming back to the same problem: is a disputed assertion false, unsupported, racist, or just being rejected? Israel enters through political theater. One speaker mocks a Florida politician's anti-AIPAC posture by pointing out that AIPAC money applies to federal elections, not state races. It is a dry point, but it lands. In his view, claims about Israel controlling everyone often work less like analysis and more like a signal to an audience already ready to hear it. The conversation eventually cools down. Asked about friends across religions, one speaker says he has Jewish, atheist, Christian, and Muslim friends, and mentions a recent episode with Qatari dissident Khalid al-Hail. The distinctions matter to him. He separates Muslims from Islamists, citing criticism of the Muslim Brotherhood, the Qatari regime, Hamas, and Hezbollah as evidence that those categories should not be collapsed. Then the episode takes a strange, calmer turn. He talks about his fascination with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, especially the overlap he sees between Jewish and Mormon histories of oppression, persecution, flight, and promised land. After all that heat, the ending is almost gentle. The participants thank each other, acknowledge the late hour, credit Reid's camera work, and leave with the sense that something was learned.

As heard by us

A tense exchange that keeps circling back to proof, definitions, and who gets to speak for whom.

This episode is a hard-edged debate about alleged assaults, antisemitism, Islam, and Israel, with Harvard sitting in the background and proof pushed to the front.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a debate that starts with Harvard and spins out toward antisemitism, faith, and who gets to fact-check whom.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Conversations with Peter Boghossian