Coffee, Murder, & Mystery · Dark and Ominous Entertainment

Missing in Kingsport TN - Layla Santanello and Hollyn Snapp

December 12, 2023·21 min·5 clips

The episode opens with a direct appeal to listeners to sit with what it means when a young woman disappears and stays missing for days, weeks, and months. That sets the tone for a return episode built around awareness rather than spectacle. The host says a TikTok from a mother of a missing girl pulled her back into covering the topic. From there, the focus turns to Kingsport, Tennessee, and to Layla Santanello. Layla is described as 20 years old, 4'10", and 115 pounds. The episode treats her very petite frame as an identifying detail that matters. It places her last seen at Eaststone Commons Shopping Center on June 27, 2023. Surveillance is said to verify that she was then seen walking toward the Kingsport Greenbelt, and the episode presents that footage as the last video anyone has of her. It then moves to an employee at Marble Slab Creamery who claims to have seen Layla or found her out back around lunchtime. The host relays that this person reportedly spoke with her, gave her food and drink, and said Layla left intending to go to Five Below to buy a cheap pair of shoes or flip-flops. The episode also notes that this sighting is disputed, with some uncertainty about whether Layla actually went to the creamery at all. Police are said to be certain she did not reach Five Below. The narration does not pretend the story is clean or simple. It raises the possibility that drugs may have been involved and mentions a motel stay as part of the background. It also pushes back against the idea that mistakes erase the need for search efforts. The host argues that vulnerability can increase risk, not reduce the need for attention. Layla is identified as the mother of a little girl named Nova Grace, and that detail is used to underline the human stakes. The episode keeps its tone plain and direct while moving through the chain of sightings and gaps. It does not try to smooth over the uncertainty. Instead, it lets the missing time feel heavy. The episode also says it is bringing attention to not one case but two missing people from Kingsport. Holland Snapp is named as the second person. The show stays anchored in concern, trying to keep both names in view. The overall effect is less like a polished mystery and more like a careful public reminder that someone still needs to be found.

As heard by us

A patient missing-persons case study that keeps the focus on detail, urgency, and a local tone.

Layla Santanello's disappearance is handled with patience and care, with the family angle kept front and center instead of treated as background detail.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Kingsport missing-persons story centered on Layla Santanello and the timeline around her last known movements.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Coffee, Murder, & Mystery