A Death In Cryptoland Introduces: Agent Pale Horse

April 1, 2025·32 min·2 clips

Scott is trying to look nonchalant, but his heart is beating louder than the rain as he faces a second security search.

The episode begins with a strong content warning for language and violence. It centers on FBI Special Agent Scott Payne and the long undercover life he built across some of the most dangerous corners of extremism and organized crime. Payne describes going deep with outlaw bikers, drug cartels, and an international neo-Nazi network. The story treats that career as a long stretch of impersonation, not just one assignment. Payne moves through aliases and roles until living a lie becomes second nature. He talks about joining the KKK one month and posing as a hired hitman the next. The episode makes plain that this work was not only dangerous but wearing. It strained his marriage, his mind, and the basic stability of daily life. Michelle Shepard introduces the series with a direct, unsentimental tone and lets Payne's account carry the weight. His voice shows how undercover work depends on patience, nerve, and judgment, and how often it means building trust with people who would destroy you if they knew who you were. The story then narrows to a property outside Rome, Georgia. There, Payne, under the alias Pale Horse, enters a gathering of members preparing for the race war they plan to spark. He notices the cars before he meets the people. One extra vehicle tells him someone new is on the property. That extra vehicle turns out to be Patrick Matthews, now using the call sign Punished Snake. Payne recognizes the accent and quickly realizes who he is. The manhunt becomes local, immediate, and personal. The episode uses that encounter to show how quickly undercover intelligence can turn from observation into consequence. It ends with the sense that this is not just a criminal case but a record of what it costs to stay convincing for 28 years.

As heard by us

Undercover reporting that treats infiltration as human cost, not a stunt.

Agent Pale Horse follows Scott Payne through years inside extremism, from outlaw bikers to drug cartels to an international neo-Nazi network with race-war ambitions. The episode stands out for treating undercover work as a human burden as much as an investigative feat.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a real undercover story, not a polished spy fantasy.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from A Death in Cryptoland